Dwight and Jim go to a meeting for a sale, but they run into trouble when a competitor is also there. They bring in Michael to combat the forces of Osprey Paper's Danny Cordray. The client goes with Danny instead of Dunder Mifflin.
After reading that one of his old classmate at Cornell has recorded a song for the Vermont milk campaign, Andy sets out to record a song of his own with Darryl and Kevin.
Michael wants to learn how Danny Cordray is such a good salesman so Dwight shows them his office that is under surveillance. They lure Danny there to find out his tricks.
They used Meredith as the boss of the fake company and she starts acting inappropriate with Danny. They send both Oscar and Ryan in to save her, but she says that neither of them can speak English, so Michael goes in to pull the plug on the sting.
Michael then convinces Danny to come work for him at Dunder Mifflin. The rest of the salesmen at Dunder Mifflin are not happy about it.