Oz checks out the cheerleading trophy in the hallway. He has an awkward interaction with Willow about their previous date. Larry teases about hooking up with both Willow and Buffy.
Willow complains to Buffy about Oz not trying to kiss her.
Xander and Cordelia are making out in her car in the woods. An animal watches them nearby. The werewolf tries to break into the car, but Cordelia drives away and the werewolf falls off.
Sunnydale High students take part in a self-defense class. Larry reveals he was bitten by a wild dog and got several stitches. Buffy is forced to pretend to be a weakling, but she throws Larry when he grabs her butt.
Giles and Buffy decide to patrol during the second night of the full moon to find the werewolf. They encounter a hunter who is also out looking for the wolf. The hunter, Cain, places Buffy in a net trap.
Cain reveals he only hunts werewolves to kill them and skin their pelts.
Theresa, a shy girl in Buffy's class, encounters Angel. He offers to walk her home and protect her.
Cordelia and Willow vent to each other about their boy troubles at The Bronze. The werewolf jumps into the club and breaks up the fun.
Buffy fights the werewolf, but he makes a run for it and escapes. The werewolf encounters Angel in an alleyway after he has killed Theresa.
In the morning, the werewolf has transformed back into Oz.
It's revealed Oz's little cousin bit him and turned him into a werewolf.
The group does some investigating of who could be the wolf. Xander confronts Larry about his potential secret as he's their top suspect. Larry reveals that he's gay; he's not the werewolf.
Buffy encourages Willow to make the first move and go after Oz.
Xander and Buffy visits Theresa's wake to see if she was killed by the wolf. Her neck wound confirms that a vampire killed her. She rises from the dead and gives Buffy a message from Angel before Xander stakes her.
Cain prepares for his next battle. He creates several silver bullets for his gun.
Willow visits Oz at his house; she makes her move but he tells her to leave. He falls to the ground and starts to change into the wolf. As the wolf, he chases her through town, but she gets away.
Buffy stops Cain from killing the werewolf; she destroys his gun as a preventative measure. Willow shoots a dart gun to knock out Oz before he does any more damage.
Larry finds common ground with Xander and acts nicer. Larry's attitude and demeanor has changed.
Willow and Oz talk about his werewolf transformations. They both agree to stay together and move forward in their relationship.