Michael Cordero - Jane the Virgin
There's a reason fans aren't able to let go of Michael, the love he felt for Jane just radiated out of every scene. It was precious getting to watch him look at Jane, always carrying hints of how much he cared for her.
Frank Castle - The Punisher
Frank looking at Karen is so pure and so soft, none of us are really worthy enough to witness them.
Michael Guerin - Roswell, New Mexico
It is ridiculous how much history and emotion you can feel from just one look between Michael and Alex. He was right when he said he never looks away, not really.
Jack Pearson - This is Us
Milo Ventimiglia's brand is based all around his ability to create meaningful relationships on screen with those looks. First Jess on Gilmore Girls and now Jack Pearson on This is Us.
Lucifer Morningstar - Lucifer
It is truly impossible to look away when Lucifer sneaks any kind of glance at Chloe.
Jake Peralta - Brooklyn Nine - Nine
I read somewhere once that Andy Samberg was more comfortable in humor than he was with romantic storylines, such as the one between Jake and Amy. It is ironic in a way considering how well he manages to capture the look that makes everyone wish they had a significant other that looked at them exactly the same way.