Mr. World - American Gods
As leader of the New Gods, Mr. World has no patience for the Gods of old. He is greedy, power hungry and obsessed with dominating everything under the sun. Mr. World will be forever stuck on Santa's naughty list no matter how much he thinks he'll one day dominate the nice side.
Lt. Gordon Malloy - The Orville
Lt. Malloy is not the worst person on the planet, but he's definitely not making the nice list. His biggest infraction of the year was when he put Mr. Potato Head pieces on Isaac's face as a practical joke. He also made Bortus eat a cactus and a virtual reality cowboy sing a silly song. Santa may have chuckled under his breath at all of Malloy's antics, but it was only because he couldn't believe Malloy's immaturity. The guy has never grown up! It's a lump of coal for him -- again!!
Brady - Mr. Mercedes
Brady did some very bad things this year, but the worst was doing nothing while his mother died a painful death because of the poisonous meat he left in the freezer that she unknowingly cooked and ate. Santa has always known Brady had a screw loose, but there was a time many moons ago when he wasn't on Santa's bad side. Unfortunately, like others on this list, Brady has become a permanent member of the naughty list club.
Lady Tremaine - Once Upon a Time
Someone worse than Regina Mills? Say it isn't so. Santa couldn't believe it himself, but Lady Tremaine has lived up to the hype. She gets an A+ for villainy and is at the top of Santa's naughty list. No amount of magic will remove her from it, and her stocking will be filled with a big piece of coal as black as her heart.
Ivar the Boneless - Vikings
Santa had high hopes for Ivar who could have turned out to be the sweetest kid on the boat. Instead, he's got a bloodlust that's unparalleled. He's more violent than his father ever was and didn't hesitate in killing his own flesh and blood. This development did not make for a very happy Santa, and Ivar immediately found himself on the wrong side of Santa's Christmas list.
Kyle West - The Arrangement
An actor's life may be difficult (at least in the actor's head), but allowing the woman you supposedly love to be kidnapped and taken against her will for a sort of reprogramming of the mind is not a good thing. Santa was rooting for Kyle and Megan, but now he's only rooting for Megan and hopes Kyle gets everything he deserves. In Santa's world, that means Kyle's only gift from the big guy will be a lump of coal.