Andy and his fellow members of the production of Sweeney Todd come to Dunder Mifflin to perform as a part of their viral marketing strategy.
Dwight and Angela continue to have problems with the contract to have a baby. Angela is trying to woo him, while Dwight just wants to fill out the punch card.
Most of the people from the office, minus Erin and Gabe, attend Andy's play. Erin babysits Jim and Pam's baby.
Michael finds out that Darryl's plumber is playing Sweeney Todd and gets extremely jealous.
Andy's phone goes off in the middle of the play, and his inability to explain the situation makes everything extremely awkward. Michael's empty bottle of wine and balloons create even more problems in the theater.
After Michael boo'd the plumber playing Sweeney Todd, he confronted Michael, who then denied it.