Marshall and the guys sit outside the inn discussing Lily's late night departure from the inn. Billy Zabka says he saw her getting into a car belonging to The Captain.
Marshall and the guys head over to his house so Marshall can confront him about Lily.
Robin's mom has arrived and tells her and Lily about her wedding day. She lists a number of odd habits her husband had which mirror some of Barney's. Robin panics because she thinks she is basically marrying her dad.
Ted thinks he has solved the case of Lily's disappearance and claims she started smoking again. It turns out she is actually pregnant. Marshall rushes back to see her and tells her they are going to live in Italy. Barney meets Robin's mother for the first time.
One year later we see Marshall and Lily arguing over Funyuns and get a glimpse at their baby daughter Daisy.