Sabrina decides to attend The Academy full time, taking a break from Baxter High now that Ms. Wardwell is the principal at the school. On the first day, she decides to run for Top Boy, which Blackwell doesn't want to accept because she is a girl. Still, she and Nick run against one another. Sabrina is attacked on her first-night studying and gets help from the Weird Sisters with the first challenge.

She gets attacked again and even with Hilda's help loses the second challenge. But this time the school is cheering for her because of her ambition. She mentions to Blackwell that she plans to become High Priestess one day which he refuses to accept.

Then for the third challenge, she gets attacked again and assumes it is Nick's fault. He says it couldn't be because the demons are too advanced even for him to call upon, so they use their third challenge to try to call upon all the demons and expose who is trying to hurt Sabrina. Instead, they reveal that they answer to no one, they just wanted to harm Sabrina because of her potential. Blackwell is angry and makes Ambroise the Top Boy instead as well as a full-time student.

Sabrina and Nick then decide to go for dinner, but see her friends and visit a witch club instead,

Elsewhere, Theo wants to try out for basketball with Harvey but isn't allowed to because the coach doesn't consider him a boy. Roz, Harvey, and Theo go to Ms. Wardwell who makes sure Theo can try out, and Sabrina is there to help him improve on his skills so he can get on the team. He then announces to Harvey and Roz that his name is Theo now.

Harvey and Roz talk about it later at dinner, and when Roz touches Harvey's hand to comfort him she sees a scene from the supposed future of Harvey kissing her.