Lauren Caffrey, a cheerleader and the fiancee of Jules Caffey, a famous defense attorne, is drowned in their bathtub and Jules is the main suspect. Jules Caffrey announces on TV that he’s hired Dr. Jason Bull, even though he hasn’t. Bull is ticked off but he still takes the case. Bull believes he’s innocent.
Benny lost to Jules more than once in court. Bull wants Jules to defend himself in court. Bull and Jules argue over the type of jury they should have and Jules doesn’t listen to Bull’s advice. Later, Bull realizes that Jules’ showmanship may be working with the jury better than he expected.
The prosecution paints Jules to be an abusive husband, but although his three ex-wives don’t like him, they all admit that he never physically hurt them.
In the end, it turns out that Lauren was a grifter who was playing Jules, and her own brother killed her.
Cable’s boyfriend, Wes, sends her two gifts and the TAC’s receptionist makes Cable suspect that he’s sending the gifts because he’s cheating. Turns out that Wes is gaming again, but Cable joins in instead of getting angry.