Willow and Xander act awkwardly around each other at the Bronze. The Scoobies think that Buffy has a secret boyfriend.
Gwendolyn Post, Faith's new watcher, arrives in town. She surprises Buffy and Faith while they're on patrol in a graveyard.
Faith is reluctant to have a new watcher. Gwendolyn is less than impressed with Giles's selection of books in the library. The Watchers Council wants Gwendolyn to report on Faith, Buffy, and the entire situation in Sunnydale.
Lagos is a demon coming to Sunnydale searching for the Glove of Myneghon.
During the next day, Buffy is doing tai chi with Angel. They're about to kiss, but she backs away.
Giles is cracking under the pressure of searching for Lagos; there are no records of him. Willow and Xander continue to flirt in the library. They makeout before being interrupted by Giles.
Faith asks Buffy about her dating situation with Angel, but Buffy isn't ready to talk about Angel. Faith goes into the graveyard alone and she fights a medieval vampire searching through a coffin.
Xander spots Angel in the graveyard; he follows him back to the mansion to find him kissing Buffy.
Angel shows Buffy the Glove of Myneghon. The weapon was hidden away in the crypt.
The Scoobies hold an intervention in the library to confront Buffy about her secret relationship with Angel. Buffy feels attacked, but Xander, Cordelia, and Giles are not happy about the development.
Buffy apologizes to Giles about keeping the secret.
Gwendolyn visits Faith in her motel. She wants to bond and make a working relationship together. She reveals that the Scoobies had a secret meeting without her.
Xander spills to Faith that Angel is alive again. Faith wants to kill Angel; both she and Xander want to visit the mansion to slay him.
Giles has all the ingredients to destroy the glove. Gwendolyn knocks him out; she's revealed to be a traitor.
Buffy and Willow have a heart-to-heart about keeping the relationship a secret. Lagos appears and Buffy slays him.
Faith and Xander find Giles severly wounded in the library. Faith thinks Angel did it; she wants to kill him.
Gwendolyn tries to kill Angel to get the glove, but they fight. Faith arrives to stop Angel and Buffy interferes to stop Faith from killing Angel. Buffy and Faith fight.
Gwendolyn puts on the glove and recites the incantation. She channels the power from the glove and attacks the Scoobies.
Buffy throws a shard of glass to chop off Gwendolyn's arm. She dies from the surge of electricity to her body.
Things are cool between the Scoobies after everything that happened.
Gwendolyn Post was a watcher, but she was kicked out for misuse of dark powers. Giles didn't read that status.
Buffy visits Faith to apologize, but the reconciliation doesn't go well. Things are still frosty between them.