They begin making the made-for-tv movie about Jack and Avery, and the actor playing Jack is a spitting image (William Baldwin). Avery's mom returns when she finds out there is a movie about her daughter, but Liz steps in to make sure she and Jack don't hook up.
Jenna writes a song for the new movie, but Weird Al parodies it. Jenna and Tracy decide to write a song so weird that even Weird Al couldn't parody it. She sings it on Jimmy Fallon, and Weird Al makes a normal version of it, getting the best of Jenna yet again.