The reason why we think it was really stupid, because Tyler is not the most sharpest apple in the barrel.Outsmarting Klaus is really difficult and it's putting a great responsbility on Tyler and actually working with it is like saying Elena is a literate person.
Well, if it's a good plan executed by a stupid person then it's useless.
There is no evidence to support that Tyler's dumb because he's not. His plan was solid until he got taken advantage of by hailey. But there is far more evidence to prove the stupidity of Elena, Klaus, all originals and the Salvatore brothers. Before you are arguing klaus he's been distracted by a teenager several times! Lol
Ummmmm believing that an actual plan to kill klaus would work no matter how solid it is! Lol TVD fans really have know logical explanation. There just upset that there murdering klaus they love was being plotted against.
stop tyler stanning, the guy is plain brawn ever since s1 he doesn't give off the smart vibe.the guy is a pure jock. Tyler has never presented any form of intelligence since s1 though. His responses to alot of things are primitively male-driven, it gives impression he's a caveman
He was dumb because he didn't have a plan B.He knew that Klaus is a 1000 years old Cray original,who's usually 10 steps ahead of everyone,if he had actually thought ahead of everything and atleast anticipated that their plan might not work and had a back up plan at hand,then it wouldn't have resulted in all of the bloodshed and his mothers death.and if he had been smart enough he would have trusted his girl friend more than a girl he just met a couple of months ago,a girl he basically knew nothing about.and she just shows up and has a plan?isn't that a least bit suspicious?shouldn't he have discussed it with his friends before trusting complete strangers?Being so naive and trusting of people he didn't know in a town full of crazies implies that he is dumb and brainless.If anyone thinks he is dumb and idiotic,i'd say they are completely justified in thinking that.