think i know who A is (Spoilers)
I think A is Spencer's Parents. In the doll shop the little kid said it was a couple with dark hair. They had access to all Spencers Contacts. They Could also get to any of Ian,Mellissa things so that they can be planted. They are acting shifty when Spencer talks to them like they know something. They hated Alli as she knew about Jason and they didnt want anyone to know. People would share private stuff with them as spencers mum is a lawyer. They would have wanted to split up Spencer and toby as they didnt like her with him. They live next door to alli's house so could have taken or gotten in there. Spencers dad was shifty when toby found the hockey stick. It was their barn he fell from and where the girls were the night alli was killed. They also would hate Ian for cheating with alli and having all those videos.
The girls have all stated they didnt guess who it was and that it was a suprise. so in the last episode they made us think it could be alli, Jenna, Melissa, Garrett. I think its too obvious for it too be them.
Spencer only is the half sister of Jason. Not of Alison (in the tv show). I haven't read all the books, so I can't tell you how it's in the books for sure.
@ LauraLu When the boy in the dollshop told them it was a couple with dark hair I was immediatly thinking about Melissa and Ian or Melissa and Garrett. But It can also be Jenna and Garrett. But Mona and Lucas also have dark hair. Or maybe it was Toby or Caleb working with a girl. There are so many people who have dark hair in the show.
So what do you guys think of the possibility that just to throw people off and its not the "same" as the books...Vivian is 'Courtney' Allisons twin. Itd be obvious if someone who looks like Alison is running around btut surgery can do a lot these days, wigs, contacts, etc. When Hanna sees dark haired Allison in the hair salon and she says "i'm pretending to be someone else - I do it quite a lot actually...maybe its cause Vivian is pretending to BE alison at that very moment.
Also, I wonder if Dr. Sullivan used to work at the Sanitarium that car shown in the Halloween episode was from, since Dr. Sullivan knows who A is and looks freaked out right away like they have history.
I think A has damn near the whole town under their twisted mentally deranged thumb. The girls think they are the only or at least main victims but what if thats the thing. A wants each victim not to tell anyone about A. They each think they are along and blame each other. It would explain why almost everyone seems suspicious.
I have a weird feeling about it but I think that Spencer is A in some way. Some of the four girls (hanna, aria, spencer or emily) is A but I really have a strong feeling about Spencer being A or atleast one of the people in the A-team.
I don't think it's Spencer - if the writers are brave enough to make one of the girls part of the A team
I want it to be Aria tho