I'm not quite sure what to think about this episode. I didn't find it that funny, but I thought the character work on Schmidt was well done. That being said...Winston singing his work will never not be funny. Pumpkinning...
1. I love that it was open. This episode reminded me of some of the lighter episodes of the X-files. 2. @Angie - YES!! LOL!! 3. I can't stand how they've stagnated the character's maturity - how did she go from one of the most intelligent, mature teenagers on television to this typical teen? I think what we also dislike is how disrespectful and inconsiderate Alexis has become towards her father. 4. I doubt Castle would name his baby daughter after Nikki Heat, a character whose sexual exploits he's written so vividly! 5. I think the final precinct scene was my fave, with both Castle and Beckett realizing that the time-travel might have been real.
castleguest - YES. Bingo.
...disrespectful, dismissive and inconsiderate to her father, and that really angers me.
The problem with Alexis is the inconsistency in her character. The reason I loved Alexis Castle is because she wasn't like any other angsty teenager on television, and I really related to that. When we first met her, she was more mature and wise than most teenagers, and as she got older, that continued. The thing is that now she's become a "typical", run-of-the-mill teenager, and that's the inconsistency. We could explain/defend her behaviour saying that any teenager would act like she would, but that's the problem. Why is she now a typical kid when she never was before? When and why did her maturity suddenly stagnate? It feels contrived and unnecessary. My other annoyance with Alexis is the way she treats her father. Say what you want about Richard Castle and his maturity level, but the man has ALWAYS been an excellent father, and continues to be. But now it's like Alexis has suddenly become unaware of that. For the past two seasons she's been absolutely disrespectful, dismissive and inconsiderate to her father, pretty much all the time, and that angers me.
ALSO - I gotta say, I'm very surprised and disappointed by NO ONE so far (reviewer or commenters) mentioning that the guest star, time traveller Simon Doyle, was Joshua Gomez from Chuck. Morgan Grimes, people! How can we talk about being nerds and not recognize a guy from one of the geekiest shows on earth? :-)
I quite enjoyed this episode - it felt like old Castle, fun and light. For the first time in a long time, they managed to make Castle believe in wild theories without making him look like a buffoon LOL. Castle and Beckett's interactions were a lot of fun, as was the entire precinct. Great episode. (sigh) I remember when I loved Alexis. Now I barely tolerate her. But I did love everything about Castle's reactions to Alexis' moving out.
THIS was the best episode of Castle in a long, LONG time. FINALLY!! 1. There were several laugh-out-loud moments. Ryan: "Oh thank God, my arm." 2. SO glad to see everyone back at the precinct, and I like that new detective - poor guy still trying to prove himself and get into the group. 3. Great interactions between Castle and Beckett, Castle and Ryan/Esposito...for once in ages, the episode felt more about Castle than anyone else. 4. SO glad Beckett got fired - I thought that was a great way to handle the Washington angle. I'm not feeling Pi - but I'm still holding out hope that he won't be wasted. I don't understand how Alexis gets LESS mature as she gets older, she was such a wise kid at the beginning. Oh well. 'Twas a good episode.
Christine, I LOVE your reviews, welcome back!! Now. First the good thing about this episode: 1. Give it up for Nathan Fillion in the acting department! From the realization that he's dying, to the torture of talking for what might be the last time to his family, to the slow deterioration of his speech with the subtle slurring - the man was in top form. Honourable mention goes to Susan Sullivan - nailed it. The bad: 1. As mentioned by practically everyone, I really hate that Beckett had practically no emotional reaction to her fiance dying. 2. The case had more holes than a colander. 3. Pi's annoying, but people on Castle aren't generally wasted, so I'm willing to see where they're going with it.
1. I think I laughed the most when SHIELD showed up at Skye's truck. "You'll never find us." LOL - the look on Coulson's face was hilarious. 2. Coulson's my fave so I really want to know about Tahiti, but I'm quite curious about Melinda May as well. 3. I tried not to speculate since I love the surprise - but Jim's theory is so good and SO comic book! 4. Tie between Coulson coming out of the dark corner: "I think there's a bulb out" and Fitz-Simmons: "And when I say luck, I mean unappreciated genius..." 5. I think Black Widow's interactions with Ward would be interesting, since Ward is supposed to have the best track record since Romanov.
Sign up for our
and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for
© 2014 TV Fanatic
Sign up for our daily newsletter to receive personalized television news for