Mondays 10:00 PM on ABC
Castle

56 Comments New Comment Subscribe

Avatar

I generally comment only when I have a lot to say, but this TERRIFIC episode spoke for itself---and what it didn't say, you commenters said for it. If it was intended to April Fool us, it worked for me! I did NOT see that ending coming! My only question is this: Does Gates now know that Castle and Beckett are an item, or does she think this was all done in the spirit of an office party?

Avatar

Excellent show. Did I hear the word Love come from Beckett?

Avatar

Alana and Joyeful? THANK YOU! THANK YOU! THANK YOU!!! Both of you said/explained it perfectly and, if you don't mind, I maybe be quoting you to others. :D

Wonderful episode! Congratulations to cast, crew, and the grat creator, Marlowe! To ABC, we need *at leat* 100 more episodes of "Castle"!

Avatar

I loved this episode! Even though I had envisioned an April Fools template, it fooled me anyway! The show just continues to get better and better and more enjoyable to me week to week. I love Caskett, and when they are kissy/feely it only makes me happier! Terrific stuff!

Avatar

Absolutely superb episode, possibly the best Castle ever. I had forgotten the date, and I'm sure I'm not the only one, which means the writers caught a whole bunch of us. So well cast and so well performed, I'm looking forward to at least another hundred...

Avatar

Looking at the clip again, non-reaction was definitely too weak. He had a reaction to the negative before recovering himself.

However, my opinion still is that that went too far. Not to sound callous but if it had been anybody other then Kate, Martha, and Alexis it would have been fine.

It also speaks to my wanting to see Kate on the defensive/reactive once in awhile. I never felt that the whole "she lied to him about remembering" thing got resolved properly, even though they got together. She didn't really formally apologize for that (although it could have been done off screen). We saw a bit of it when Castle was locked up wrongly, but I want to see a bit more of it. And I'm sure Stana could do it, she's a very capable actress.

Avatar

LOVED this episode!!!! I only started watching Castle in January and I’m hooked. Like Castle, I was completely in the dark until the lights turned on. Both Beckett and Castle looked stunning! The whole cast is perfect.
@Alana: I agree about Castle’s reaction - Fillion’s acting was excellent.

Joyeful

@Alana - that's exactly what I was trying to say, you just said it SO much better LOL. I completely agree.

Avatar

One of the best episodes ever. Completely fooled just like Castle. To go to this much planning for a birthday shows how much Castle is loved. Love this show!

Avatar

Just writing to say that was an AMAZING Castle episode - and Lanie was at the party! She's right behind Beckett when the lights come up and If you can drag yourself away from Caskett when they are making out you see Esplanie making out too! lol




You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register