Smash Review: Reinventing the Shows

by at . Comments

The worlds of the three musicals on Smash all righted themselves on "Musical Chairs," with Jerry the one left without a place to sit.

Bombshell returned to Eileen's control with Tom directing and Ivy as Marilyn. And The Hit List got a production deal from a non-profit theater with Jimmy and Karen as the leads with Derek directing. And Liaisons got put out of its misery, but not before an epic performance.

Katie to the Rescue

Liaisons bombs
Ivy cracked me up when she responded to Terry's concern over the "meh" reviews. The show had improved, but it was horrible to start. Their decision to have fun with it was probably not the professional one, but it was worth it to see Terry's act. That was hilarious. Horrible, but a performance that no one in the audience will ever forget.

With the production shutting down, it freed Ivy to rejoin Bombshell as Marilyn. I liked Karen in the role, but Ivy was always better in the part. If Ivy hadn't self-destructed during Smash season 1, it wouldn't have been a contest. It's not always about the best performer, but the best fit that gets the job. And, Ivy is the best Marilyn and the perfect fit to work with Tom.

The Hit List gets a theater
Jimmy and Ana preformed for Scott and the non-profit theater board. They loved the show and Scott wanted to produce it. The hitch was that he wanted it for their small 80-person underground theater stage. Derek was understandably disappointed. The move from a Broadway show to a tiny theater was not what he had in mind. Scott suggested they clarify a theme and better broadcast it for the show and present it again.

I've defended Jimmy's attitude up until this point, but no more. His refusal to make any changes to the show went beyond protecting his creative vision. It showed his ignorance about the process of making a musical and his immature arrogance at his talent. He's a gifted song writer, but that doesn't mean his vision was the best for the production. If he wasn't going to at least consider the producer's input, then Derek should have run away and not stopped.

With Tom directing Bombshell, it was inevitable that Karen would leave and join The Hit List. Jimmy and Kyle's show is a better fit for her talents. Though, I'm not sure how she could afford to leave a Broadway show for the smaller production. Sometimes, it's the love of the work though and not the paycheck. She showed her dedication by giving up the higher profile job as well. 

Jimmy and Karen performed a new song, "Rewrite This Story." Scott and the theater board loved it and were enthusiastic about producing the show. It was a beautiful song that set the tone and theme for the musical. Jimmy also started to redeem himself by listening to the criticism of the show, working on changes, and most importantly acknowledging Scott's input. Jimmy's comment to Scott was a small thing, but for him it was a huge shift in attitude.

Bombshell get a new life
The future of the show was at risk with Jerry holding it quietly hostage and with Tom as director. Eileen decided that she either wanted the show back or she would force it out of production. It was a risky move, but worked in her favor. Julia found the "silver bullet" to take Jerry out of the picture. Eileen held the rights to using Marilyn's diaries, which made up a good portion of the book.

Eileen threatened to withhold those rights and close down the show, if Jerry didn't give it back to her. With their daughter on board, Jerry acquiesced. If we never see Jerry again, that would be fine with me. He is such a slimy guy. It was touching though to see Eileen share with her daughter the happier times of their marriage.

Bombshell's production started to fall into place. Eileen was in charge, Tom was directing, Ivy was in as Marilyn, Derek signed over the choreography rights, and Julia convinced Tom to keep Marilyn's mother storyline in. This is Broadway though and troubles will certainly arise, but at least they had their happy moment and toasted the production.

The trouble with Karen
Karen's decision to join The Hit List was the best for her and the production, but it could drive both Jimmy and Derek crazy. She clearly has feelings for Jimmy and that was part of the reason she joined the production. She quickly agreed to go out for drinks with him and looked excited at the idea. 

Then, Derek came in and messed everything up. Karen has been his muse, but Derek has never showed that kind of possessiveness over her before. It's not healthy and will certainly lead to conflict on the show. Will Karen continue to be blind to what's going on? Or, will she figure it out and clarify her feelings for both men?

There's a time for a good love triangle, but I don't see it working well here. Karen has never seen Derek in that way and I don't see that changing. Even though Jimmy has an attitude problem, Karen is able to challenge him and sees the best in him. Even without Derek's interference, a relationship between two leads on a show would be difficult. Maybe now that Ivy is back on Bombshell and Derek has his own show, they could get back together and make it work.

Is everyone now in the right place for them professionally? What do you make of Derek's sudden possessiveness? Which show will hit the stage first?

Review

Editor Rating: 4.5 / 5.0
  • 4.5 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.1 / 5.0 (53 Votes)

Carla Day is a staff writer for TV Fanatic. Follow her on Twitter and on Google+.

Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more Smash?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic

Facing-off-against-kate

Teen Wolf Review: No One Else Dies

Scott decides to get tough on Teen Wolf after rescuing his Beta by declaring he won't sit back and watch more deaths. Find out what else went down in the review!
Debating-at-dinner

The Real Housewives of Orange County Review: Pity Party, Table For One

Heather and Tamra consider making peace with Shannon on The Real Housewives of Orange County. See what went down in our TV Fanatic review!
Winding-down

Murder in the First Review: And the Verdict Is...

On Murder in the First, the trial of Erich Blunt reaches its conclusion. But what is the verdict? Find out when you read the review.
Andi-dorfman-on-the-finale

The Bachelorette Review: Andi Dorfman Is Engaged To...

Andi Dorfman chooses between Nick Viall and Josh Murray. Find out who she chose now on our The Bachelorette review!

Avatar

Karen and Jimmy need to end up together. First off Derek is controlling Karen , he feels that she is his. Karen doesn't actually love Derek so they can't be a thing. Karen is head over heels for Jimmy she keeps going back to him no matter what. Jimmy and Karen like each other a lot it'll take great effort but it'll end up working. Karen from the beginning wouldn't sleep with Derek for the role and still won't do it , no matter if he "respects" her. Derek seems the same only want Karen and her looks.derek and Ivy always had chemistry and will find a way I mean he is still attracted to her when he tried to kiss her after giving a big speech to her about how she is fantastic. Karen and Jimmy and Derek and Ivy simple as.

Avatar

Team Derek!!! All the way!!!

Avatar

I can't believe I'm saying this, but Jimmy is more annoying than Ellis. This show made a huge mistake hiring the showrunner from Gossip Girl. That show had nonexistent ratings... what did NBC expect he'd do for Smash? He's done exactly what he did for his previous show.

Vv

I really hope cartwills happens before the show gets cancelled! We waited 2 seasons for them! And while I think jimmy is a very good singer and both his duets with karen were wonderful, I just can't stand him when he's not singing! Please if they must happen (as the promo seems to suggest) then I wish it'll be a quick fling and she will get with derek in the end!

Avatar

Karen & Jimmy singing together is amazing! LOVE SMASH! Yay, HIT LSIT! I think this will be the break out show on Broadway!
Love Derek's attitude about Karen!

Avatar

This episode was fantastic! For the love of god please don't cancel this show.

Avatar

Seriously, folks, Karen will NOT be happy with Jimmy. She is attracted to his musical talent - but he's been a jerk to her. He does not respect her - Derek respects her immensely! Derek knows that she has a certain fragility and he is being careful with that. I do not think he actually wants a relationship with her right now but he KNOWS that Jimmy "wham-bam-thank you ma'aming" her into the sack will just destroy the possibility of a workable production. Jimmy needs to mind his manners and grow up until he is ready for a "giving" relationship, not just a "taking" relationship. If you disagree to yourself, think - when has Jimmy ever shown actual concern for her feelings?

Sarah-silva

I loved every moment, except the last couple minutes when Derek decided Karen was his and pretty much told Jimmy that!
We all kenw that Ivy would end up back at Bombshell, as Marilyn this time and that Karen would head to Hit List.
I really liked how it all happened, Karen seeing Ivy and Tom together after Liasons and saying that they could make it work but there would be something missing and that Ivy is his Marilyn. Then I loved Tom telling Karen she was a class act! I am glad that Eileen finally has bombshell and Jerry is left out!
I am mad at Derek, Karen is not interested in you Derek! Just let her be happy with Jimmy.

Avatar

Karen and Derek, all the way! Jimmy is an immature idiot! Viewers have been waiting since last season to see Karen and Derek happen. Never liked Derek with Ivy. Jimmie belongs with his writing partner, who is actually in love with him. Quite honestly, if Karen and Derek don't happen, I'd be happy to see the show cancelled. That relationshipis what puls me in.

Avatar

I'm glad Ivy is finally rewarded by getting the role she was meant to play. Karin's character is so bland that despite her lovely voice she has never had the power to move me. I wonder if this switching of roles was intended from the beginning or a new wrinkle to try to build interest this season when numbers are way down.