Once Upon a Time Round Table: "In the Name of the Brother"

at . Comments

"In the Name of the Brother" brought back Frankenstein's monster and exposed Storybrooke to the outside world.

Below, our Once Upon a Time Round Table of TV Fanatic writers Nick McHatton, Jim Garner, and Carla Day are joined by Gareth from Once Upon a Fan to debate Rumple and Belle's future and whether a horror story monster belongs in the fairy tale universe.


What was your favorite scene?

Gareth: Belle throwing the Chipped Cup was heartbreaking. As a symbol of their relationship, seeing it destroyed like that really got to me. In that moment, I think Rumple lost all hope that he could get Belle back. This was a powerful scene that touched many fans.

Nick: I loved Ruby's chat with Dr. Whale about finding the good in Storybrooke. They both have a past that haunts them, but they finally have a shot at putting it behind them even though they are "cursed" to Storybrooke. The Star Wars ringtone was awesome, also.

Jim: I loved watching Rumple dump out the coins. They would flicker between between and color and just kept coming. My inner-DnD geek screamed "bag of holding."

Carla: When Henry realized that Dr. Frankenstein's story wasn't in his book. I didn't understand why that character was included on the show, but at least it was recognized in some way. Though, he was present in Fairy Tale Land in his first origin episode, right?

Once Upon a Time RT - depreciated -

Do you think Regina will join forces with Cora?

Gareth: Definitely. Evil is brewing in Storybrooke. I think Cora will use Henry as the instrument for getting Regina to do exactly what she wants. However, I am hoping for a 'Darth Vader' moment further down the road when Regina turns on Cora.

Nick: No more than is necessary.

Jim: I'm hoping she is playing Cora to find out what she wants. I would hate to think of the two of them actually working together.

Carla: I hope not. Cora's playing her daughter and I hope Regina is just manipulating her back.

Does Frankenstein belong in the Once Upon a Time universe?

Gareth: Yes. The writers have always stated that all kinds of stories would be explored on the show. This opens up the show to new worlds and characters, keeping the show fresh. My only concern would be that the core characters don't suffer as a result of too many new introductions.

Nick: He does now, as Henry pointed out that the curse swept up people with different stories. While it would be nice to have just Disney past and characters, but it would be hard to sustain a show over the long term restricted to that. Is Frankenstein the best fit in the universe? Not necessarily, but, boiled down, his themes do run the same as Once's, and that's really my only requirement that the more "out there" in terms of relation to fairy tales are molded in a way that fits with the themes of the show.

Jim: Absolutely, pulling characters from other works of fiction allow for a much broader and well rounded world. Just because he wasn't a "fairytale" doesn't make it any less of a "story" now does it?

Carla: No. As I mentioned above, I hated his inclusion initially. This episode didn't change that. It could also be because I wanted a happier character for Dr. Whale.

Should Rumple have left Belle to go look for Baelfire?

Gareth: I think Rumple truly believes Belle is lost to him at this stage. All he has left now is Baelfire, so all of his energy and time will be devoted to the search for him. His son is the only thing keeping him from falling into total darkness.

Nick: I can't blame him wanting to look for Bael since Belle is freaking out whenever she's around him, plus his original intention for helping create the curse is to find Bael, so it's not surprising Rump's going to continue looking for his son even if Belle became harmed along the way.

Jim: Yeah, she needs time. Hell, Rumple needs time. I'm really surprised he didn't turn Hook or the Witness into a rat, mouse, bird before he left.

Carla: Stay or go, either decision would have made sense. Since Belle is distraught when he's around and Cora provided the means for him to find Bael, he shouldn't feel bad for leaving Belle behind.

Out of all of the great Once Upon a Time quotes, who had the best line of the episode?

Gareth: "Emma, Henry and the two idiots."  It really made me laugh. Lana Parilla delivers sassy lines so effortlessly. Although Ruby's "I ate my boyfriend" came a close second.

Nick: Emma's "In a normal town the Sheriff goes in and asks a few questions. She doesn't bring her parents in with her."

Jim:  Emma's "You're chained down. He's on his feet, immortal, has magic, and you hurt his girl. If I were to pick dead guy of the year, I'd pick you."

Carla: When Regina referred to Mary Margaret and David as "the two idiots." That cracked me up.

C. Orlando is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow her on Twitter.


@queenbee - I was on OUAT's Facebook page, and the general feeling there was one of horror upon seeing the Rumple-Cora smooch. It was more one-sided though as Rumple looked particularly repulsed with her gesture. I think we all want to forget it ever happened, until it has a more definite impact to the current story.


how come nobody's saying anything about the Rumple/Cora kiss??? This is major! They used to be a couple. Very intrigued by this development... is it too soon to have "Corumple"-shipper wars?


@KansasGuest thanks for the info on my guest post as @phoebe I really appreciate it =D


guys a question totally out of the blue but it has been bothering me:
WHERE THE HELL IS AUGUST (PINOCCHIO)? Honestly, they forgot all about him and not even his father is banging on doors trying to figure things out. after that teary scene at the finale of season 1 when Emma left him on the bed to go break the curse and save him i thought she wouldn't just up and forget his existence the next day. it is like the curse is deleting him from the memories of all the characters.WTH?


1. I'm siding with Nick here. We got a monsteromance brewing!
2. I hope not. I really hope Regina is playing Cora because you can't go from wanting somebody dead to working together....ever.
3. Siding with Jim on this one.
4. Sure, he's gotta give her time. I'm surprised she didn't have any other visitors. Where was Ruby?
5. Can the Star Wars ringtone count as Best Line?


I loved the teacup scene, even though it made me cry. I think that Rumple was right to go look for Bae even when it meant leaving Belle because Jim was right, she needs time to process everything that she will find out she has gone through, and in that time I know that somehow, someway Belle will regain her memories. My favorite lines from the show were Regina's "two idiots" line (priceless), and Rumple's "If any harm comes to Belle while I'm away, I will kill all of you." (Or something like that). It for me just strengthened that yeah even though he is leaving, he will never forget about Belle for even one second because of how much he loves her. Oh and Hook and Emma's hospital scene was just awesome too.


@Phoebe - BTW, my comment below is an example of how NOT to do it. First, you become a registered user. Then, you should sign in (without writing any comment). Then, once the screen confirms you are logged in as "XXX," write you comment in the Comment Box and hit "Submit Comment." Your name should highlight in blue, and then you'll be able to refer to past comments written after becoming a registered user. See my name about this comment as an example. Good luck!


@Mike - I agree about Emma & Regina. They've certainly had heartfelt discussions about Henry that bring them closer to having a mature, civil relationship. And, Regina knows that Emma would protect Henry with her life, which probably brings Emma up a couple of notches. Don't know if I'd go as far as "friendship." But, they do respect each other when it comes to making Henry happy. @Phoebe - You can't. There is no way to connect an anonymous user/guest to their comments. There has to be some sort of link. The only way to link comments back to an individual is for that person to register as a user. Registered users have to log on so all their posted comments will be saved for future review.


I wrote my more than is shown


how can you view a comment you've already submitted as a guest?

Tags: ,