The Vampire Diaries Round Table: "My Brother's Keeper"

at . Comments


Sorry, we got distracted there for a second, as The Vampire Diaries provided plenty of fodder for our Round Table team - comprised of staffers Matt Richenthal, Leigh Raines, Steve Marsi and Miranda Wicker - to discuss in "My Brother's Keeper."

Highlighted by a certain closing scene that exposed both secrets and skin...


What was your favorite scene from the episode?
Matt: Stefan prompting Jeremy to kill that newly-turned vampire, no doubt. That was some seriously intense stuff and it furthered the show's best storyline at the moment: Jeremy's murderous urges and that ever-growing mark.

Leigh: I love Tyler, but I found myself oddly drawn to the scenes between Klaus and Caroline. I think there's a chemistry there, whether Caroline like it or not. He was the only person keeping her calm and entertained during the pageant.

Steve: Klaus making his move on Caroline. Being the most powerful creature on Earth only gets you so far when it comes to women apparently ... fool's gotta run game like anyone else (if only we all had that accent). Second place? Jeremy morphing into a mini-Connor before our eyes. Third place? Any scene with Hayley for obvious reasons, if you get what I'm insinuating. What I'm insinuating is that she's not unattractive.

Miranda: It feels too easy to say Damon and Elena, but I've been waiting for that since the balcony on The Vampire Diaries Season 3. I also really loved Klaus and Caroline and almost, for half a second, started to think they should give a relationship the old college try. I kind of think I wouldn't hate it if they did. Bonus favorite scene: Matt moving in with Jeremy. Was his house finally foreclosed on? Was he finally evicted? I mean, I can't imagine he was making enough at The Grill to pay that bill every month.

Vampire Diaries RT - depreciated -

More likely to hook up: Matt and April, Stefan and Caroline or Hayley and Tyler?
Matt: I have no clue how Tyler will be able to resist Hayley after seeing her in that dress (especially if she breaks out the Australian accent soon), until I remember that he's dating the amazing Caroline Forbes. Matt, meanwhile, is way too nice to get down and dirty with anyone... so let's give it up for Scaroline, everyone! They will soon drown their sorrows over Delena by drowning in one another's hot bods!

Leigh: Hayley and Tyler for sure. Hayley wants it, Tyler is gonna get mad at Caroline inevitably over something Klaus related. Plus, you don't bring Phoebe Tonkin to guest star on your show if you're not gonna show off her sexy side!

Steve: Matt and April, without a doubt. Who's NOT waiting for that? TVD water cooler topic of the spring, mark my words.

Miranda: More likely? Hayley and Tyler. Paws down. But I'm hoping Matt, April and Jeremy become the new triangle. I could see there being something supernatural about her where she's the only one who can help him control his urge to hunt.

The Delena sex scene: All you ever dreamed about, or a total letdown?
Matt: As I mentioned once or two dozen times in my Vampire Diaries review of the episode, any positive feelings I possessed over these two were wiped away by the siring nonsense. Was the scene scorching? Of course. But my brow was more furrowed over Caroline and Stefan's discussion than any other body parts of mine were... nevermind.

Leigh: Hot hot hot! I don't ship one brother over the other. Well done. I enjoyed how it started off with the dancing. And I wonder if Ian and Nina's offscreen chemistry makes it easier onscreen.

Steve: See last night's Vampire Diaries review by Matt for my sentiments exactly. Hot, sure, but a total letdown thanks to the contrived sire bond, a twist made even more lame by Caroline's drawn-out epiphany. Sorry, C. Not even you could sell me on that.

Miranda: All I ever dreamed about. And more. I don't for one second buy the "The Sire Bond Made Me Do It" angle. Not even a little bit. And I'm actually kind of peeved that even now there's still some angle for WHY she has feelings for Damon. It's okay for her to have feelings for Damon, and those feelings existed before she was turned even if she wouldn't admit it. He never said "Hey, VampElena, have feelings for me and me only." Sire bond, schmire bond. THAT WAS HOT.

What is Professor Shane's endgame?
Matt: Easy. He wants to un-sire all hybrids? Maybe kill Klaus? Find a cure and put an end to the existence of vampires, if not every supernatural in the world? He's working undercover for TNT, trying to get The Vampire Diaries canceled.

Leigh: Well, he wants all of the hybrids un-sired... so it's safe to say he knows about Klaus. Perhaps he wants to cure Klaus? Hunt him? Certainly wouldn't make him the first person with such desires.

Steve: If he played a role in murdering the entire council, which he kind of obviously did, his endgame can't be as simple as killing Klaus for the sake of it. Maybe he just wants that charming Original out of the way so he can have the Cure all to himself. Shane mentored Connor in addition to Bonnie, so he's gotta be after that first and foremost.

Miranda: Either he IS Silas, or he wants to awaken Silas. And he's hellbent on destruction. I don't trust him.

What would you hope to accomplish as Miss Mystic Falls?
Matt: World peace is probably out, considering the events that take place in this town alone. I'd probably start a Stay in School campaign. Seriously, when was the last time these seniors attended class?!?

Leigh: To just keep breathing. In this town, you never know when your time is up! Also, I'd open up another hangout besides the Mystic Grill. We need a little variety.

Steve: The way things are going these days? Living long enough to hand the crown to Miss Mystic Falls 2013. That and modernizing the school's mascot ... the 1994 Minnesota Timberwolves called, guys, they want their logo back.

Miranda: World Peace? Life insurance policies for workers at The Grill? A truancy officer to check on why all these kids aren't attending school? Making sure no one ever cares that all these teenagers are drinking in public?

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.


I have never liked Elena no matter who she was with... poor Elena, it has always been poor Elena and how she is miserable (well, look at all the people she got killed). I love Caroline, strong and owns up.
I am about 5 episodes behind...but I can't stand much more of poor Elena, thank goodness I record this so I can fast forward through the Elena crap.


I agree Miranda. I'm peeved too that they containmented the Damon/Elena hot sex scene without trying to explain as a 'siring' thing? Why can't it just be because she is no longer constrained by the morality of her past human life and that she is more free to make her own decisions? I personally like her with Damon. She seems more of life (no pun intended). With him it isn't like a little girl wringing her hands over Stefan, but like a woman with passion. It's a no brainer for me.


The only thing that could be better than being sired to Damon would be being sired to Elijah - FOREVER.

David and sabrina 2014

This episode is still a TOTAL LETDOWN and VERY DISAPPOINTING!!!!!!


anya, you probably dont pick up a lot of social cues right?


Honestly, I don't really feel the chemistry btw Delena, but I definitely do btw Selena. And I can't believe Elena would fall for Damon after loving Stefan even in his darkest time.


I don't get it...there's so much killing and other bad stuff going on in this show but what disturbs people the most is the characters being whores and bad brothers? That's nonsense. Katherine isn't better than Elena idiots. She was sleeping with both brothers at the same time! Turned both of them into vampires, played each one against each other on purpose! Where Is your logic people? The only person who isn't a whore on the show is Bonnie. Caroline has been a slut since season 1 remember. She was a fast ass easy teenager. And she slept with best friends I.e. matt and Tyler...hello? Has anyone been watching the show?


Elena is an effing whore for sleeping with Damon after breaking up with Stefan all in a matter of 2 days. Stefan and Elena dated for soooo long and this is how she deals with the breakup? U would think stefan and elena only dated for a month The way she Just ran to Bed with damon. omfg. Used to think Katherine was horrible but compared to Elena, Katherine is Sooo much better!


Seriously they just turned Elena into a cold hearted whore and Damon into the world's shittiest brother! Two things those characters are not! Congrats crappy TVD writers! I wish we could start over, the first thing I would do is resolve the whole Katherine story line appropriately, I think this is when the writing started to go down the hill!


1. I would've said Delena sex, but it was horrible, so no. And as much as I hate Caroline now - nothing can take away from Klaus, so all the Karoline moments. Also, whey Hayley put on the tiara and Tyler said that the other will cut her. I lol'd so much.
2. Karoline will never happen, god only knows why, such great chemistry! I'm really not sure something meaningful will happen woth the werewolves also, so Matt - you win! YAY!
3. Worse then let down - it was a cop out. But if we take the actual context out of it, then hot hot hot. Must've been so embarrassing for them tho, Having to bring such a privet thing to a room full of people to judge.
4. Something that we now can't see but will eventually be something so obvious. World domination maybe?
5. Better mortality mojo bling. For man and vampires!!

Tags: ,

The Vampire Diaries Season 4 Episode 7 Quotes

Let's not pretend like this isn't the best day of your life.


I'm not depressed. I just wanna rip into someone's artery and feed until I can't feed anymore.