Fringe Review: Hardened

at . Comments

The differences between Etta and her family were highlighted during "In Absentia."

Etta is hardened to the ways of the world and not easily swayed at taking the long way around what she considers an easy problem. But her ways of dealing with so-called easy problems are also uncaring and far from compassionate. 

Looking For Power

The time frame between when the Observers took over and when the Fringe team were ambered was only a few months, and watching Olivia, Peter and Walter try to reconcile the short period in their minds with the lengthy one they've missed is equally intriguing and sad. Where we have our team doing their utmost to protect those who may be innocents caught in the crossfire, we have Etta unconcerned with their innocence or guilt.

She's only concerned with the team they chose, not their reason for making the choice.

For Etta, things are black and white. It's not yet easy to feel for her, because we don't have the decades of knowledge of this strange new world in which she lives. For the first time, our Fringe team is at the disadvantage. They need to trust their daughter, that their genes were strong enough to permeate whatever the universe threw at her and that she would benefit from the very best of them and her own horror of what she has lived through.

The truly incredible thing about this particular route to the story is Olivia was never thought of as exceptionally emotional. She was the skeptic and the brain, Peter the heart and soul. Adding Etta gives new dimension to Olivia and it's so natural. As much as she tried to deeply question the Loyalist, her heart got in the way. Etta knew he was manipulating her, and the pain Olivia felt at the realization of what Etta suffered in her lifetime her lift gutted her.

The Loyalist lied to Olivia until the end, and Etta was right all along. The Observers changed our world far more than our Fringe team could grasp.

How long will it take for for her to be back in the presence of her family for the emotional aspect of being a Bishop to drip onto Etta? More importantly, how will that harm her? As much as I'd love for her to feel something that would provide her a genuine emotional connection with her family, that affection could lead to her letting down her guard and get them all killed. Even when she saw Simon's head, her despair was shown through anger and the need for vengeance rather than rather than something softer. What a shame if it's a means of survival and Etta never gets to feel that familial connection she has searched for her entire life.

Seeing Simon in that way was definitely not what I had in mind when I said I wanted to see him again. I guess there is little room to explore avenues in such a short season with so much to cover, but that was downright shocking. A lovely reveal would have been William Bell's head next to Simon, carrying on a conversation with him. That could still be coming, I suppose, as could many other things. I don't have hope for the positive, however, as the future seems to be an ugly place.

Just a quick note about Walter and his Betamax message. Was I the only one who felt like we've now entered into a game of Myst or something? We'll have a series of puzzles to solve and at the end of each one will be a video that will tell us how to get to another section of this new world and there will be something else to solve and at the very end we'll be treated to a roller coaster ride that will take us back in time and erase the atrocities of the Observers.

Hey - it could happen!!


Editor Rating: 4.5 / 5.0
  • 4.5 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.9 / 5.0 (933 Votes)

Carissa Pavlica is the managing editor and a staff writer for TV Fanatic. Follow her on Twitter and on Google+.


Great episode though less point A to B to C woud be better.


Olivia Dunham has always been compassionate, caring , her empathy has always been the reson she was so good at her job.
WATCH the pilot and season 1 etc, Olivia caring for Walter, Olivia feeling the pain from the victims. It is a wonder that Olivia still had that empathy, after her childhood, the abuse by Bell, Walter, stepfather, no mother to take care of her. So no excuse for Etta, she is cold, empty,
and Altlivia was not cold in her own world, only when she was undercover, and even then she had feelings. They have now spent more time to establish Ettas backsstory in 2 epi than they have with Olivia in 4 seasons. Standout was Anna Torv, beautiful subtle acting, dominating all the scenes by expressions, eyes and face.
She does not need the gadgets etc.


I guess it's nature versus nurture. With the alternate universe we have seen that under different circumstances both Walter and Olivia could become very cold and ruthless. We saw the same with Peter when he started killing the shape shifters for research. She comes from a family that tends toward single minded determination to accomplish a goal whatever cost. I have a theory about her disappearing. What if she crossed universes. Olivia was at the beginning of her pregnancy when she lost the cortexiphan so what if some went into the fetus. A scared Etta could have crossed universes and found her parents gone when she finally got back.

Tags: ,

Fringe Season 5 Episode 2 Quotes

Criterion collection, forgive me.


When did I switch to grape?