American Idol Results: The Top Two Are... Comments (Page 2)
88 Comments
Xoxie
May 21st, 2012 4:59 PM
P2????Are you kiddin' me?It's JESSICA ALL OVER THE WORLD..PEOPLE VOTE FOR JESSICA for the win...
jeff
May 21st, 2012 4:56 PM
JESSICA FOR THE WIN!!!
sarah
May 21st, 2012 4:55 PM
JESSICA FTW!!Big NO to P2..
rick
May 21st, 2012 12:08 AM
Consider it done Jessica won first week albums sales over 1 million copies. Jessica is an awesome Chinese American who has won are hearts.
wayne
May 19th, 2012 11:40 PM
Joshua's version of Imagine was a disaster. That scared cow of a song should not be done unless you understand the song's message. Joshua over sang the song, which he does to all songs, but, the simplicity and purity of the song's message was buried under Josh's overly dramatic performance. It is almost criminal what he did to that song.
Dino_me
May 19th, 2012 10:24 AM
Get over it if your favorite idol contestant did not make the finale. Both Jessica and Philip are in the finale simply because more fans voted for them . Although winning AI is one big achievement and a stepping stone for a future music career we all know by now that post idol it does not guarantee the winner a successful music career. If you truly believe in the talent of your endeared idol contestant continue to support him/her post idol. That is where your genuine support will truly matter.
Audy
May 18th, 2012 9:17 PM
@ Robert D, don't they all impersonate? don't they all sing songs not theirs? they are all copy cats, not only jessica, not only joshua not only philip but the rest of AI singers. Couldn't be helped! IT IS WHAT IT IS
nc
May 18th, 2012 8:22 PM
As much as I didn't want it to happen, I knew Joshua was next to go. He will have more success than all of the other contestants put together--I hope producers don't "Usher" him up and put him in videos with half-naked girls--if there was still a Motown, he would be the next Motown Icon--he is amazing. Jessica and Philip are, in my opinion, one trick ponies--as a matter of fact they bore me. I won't be watching next week--the show will be a yawner. I agree. I can picture Jessica in front of her mirror with a hair brush, mimicing Whitney, etal--and she is too young to be in the show. Phil will win--all of the teenage girls will vote for him.
Terrie Rank: Regular Character
May 18th, 2012 5:43 PM
You know I've just set here and read ALL these comments.
All of you hollering "I'm not watching AI anymore" ........no doubt you'll watch the finale next week.........
I do think Jessica should have went home. And the main reason is she is just too young. I don't feel 16 year olds should be on the show and subjected to that kind of pressure. She can sing yes, but to me it's just imitations of the originals and she needs more time to grown.
Joshua can sing as well and I feel that he's going to be fine. He needs to prove that he can move away from gospel (in other words, BE MORE VERSITLE) and the 10 backup singers and the screaming.
I am still pulling for Phillip to win it. It is of no consequence to me that a girl hasn't won in several years.
solofia Rank: Recurring Character
May 18th, 2012 5:18 PM
At least the top 2 aren't two dudes like 3 years ago...
Lyn
May 18th, 2012 2:50 PM
To Janie Juser, I just hpoe you are really a gorgeous beyond belief woman because if I have to guess your personality based on your shameful out of line comments you are one ugly , evil spirited creature reeked with odor that comes from all the feces of human and animals. Why on earth you would comment about Jessica's teeth when we are talking about singing competition. My guess is you can not criticize her singing that is credible.
AromaGirl
May 18th, 2012 12:04 PM
You can have Jessica, BORING!!!!!!, too bad about Joshua, love PP, mostly 'cause the judges don't & he sticks to who he is!!!!
V
May 18th, 2012 11:45 AM
Joshua deserved to be in the finale with Philip. I'm sad he left but I think it's a good thing, he won't be tied to the AI machine and he can carve out a career for himself. Right now I don't care who wins but if I must choose i would prefer Philip to win just because I believe Jessica still has some growing up to do. There's something that puts me off pageant stiff way of singing. Somehow I think she will win it all for two reasons (1) It's time a woman (girl) won (2) The filipino's are treating it like the second coming (including their President).
dyno
May 18th, 2012 11:35 AM
Continued: I would like to have seen all three of them sing the same song. They could have done a recorded version. Joshua's back ground is gospel, i rarely go to church, but when has it ever been wrong to do so. He was not screaming. He was hitting notes. Something Phillips can't do. Phillips was straining just to hold a note on his last song. America go it Wrong and Idol is rigged. No more Idol for me. Tired of it all.
Dyno
May 18th, 2012 11:18 AM
Joshua could flat out sing. He put pashion and sould into his music and performances. You made a point, Joshua is not marketable if possibly compared to Phillips because of his stle of music and demographics. Phillips songs did not have any type of techinical difficulty. Although I like him and he performances were relaxed, he cannot hold at note and the way he rounded notes were predictable and evident he cannot sing. He talked his songs. His voice has good tone, but that's it. They made Phillips seems has if he was in the bottom two, when he might have been in the top two last week. They did the same thing last night. They potrayed Jessica as she was ahead on votes, but honestly Phillips could have been. I did not think the true winner would win because demographics plays and important role. Joshua left it out there every time and all of his performance were nice. Phillips is mediocre and you can find people all over the south and other select parts of the country doing the same sty
atm Rank: Recurring Character
May 18th, 2012 10:46 AM
i think philip philips is just like david cook...and kris allen...and lee dwyze. pretty boy semi-rocker dudes with a guitar. and where are they now? we have too many guys like philip already. as for jessica, i think she can be a true diva. and she can also be a fashion icon and trendsetter.
peter
May 18th, 2012 10:27 AM
Jessica sounded awful on Wednesday who said artist want to sign her ?? Honestly most artist hate American idol cause they think these guys are over privileged when they had to work so hard to get to where they are today in other word these guys haven't paid there dues. And the judges gave standing o's to Joshua cause he's good ..do u guys not remember Jessica was already voted off ? Then the judges got up there and said she is onE of the best singers in the world ? Lol really? haha the most successful at to come out of ai in last 5 years is Adam Lambert and u saw just how great he was last night right? Everyone else is pretty much no where or soon to be dropped for there labels . We just can't pick em let the music business do there jobs and find talent on there own cancel shows like this it creates a bad image for music
Jessica will win because not just Americans are voting. Mexicans and Phillipinos around the world are voting also with Magic Jack and computers.
Janie Juser
May 18th, 2012 9:45 AM
PLEASE I mean really....please get rid of Jessica at the finale...I cannot stand to look at those teeth hanging out when she sings!!!!! GO PHILLIP PHILLIPS!!!!!!
K
May 18th, 2012 9:35 AM
Well what father welcomes his son home with a gun attached to his pants Think Phillip Phillips .Such a shame America that the real Singer has been eliminated.I guess gun culture is really alive and well spirituality (Joshua ) vs (redneck) guns America no wonder Joshua felt relieved to be leaving who wants to be aligned with that energy shame on you Phillip Phillips Snr even Ryan Seacrest pointed it out .Time to vote Joshua back in .
jr
May 18th, 2012 9:16 AM
Why isn't Phillip in any of the Ford videos?
decalf
May 18th, 2012 8:57 AM
Yes, I know Phil's gonna win. But here's hoping I'm wrong on this one... It's been a while since we have a female actually worthy of winning American Idol. I think Lauren from last year didn't have that, so I'm not surprised to see Scotty eventually win it. But Jessica, she's just too good to not win. And if we really look back, American Idol used to be a singing competition - so basically the title should go to the best singer. But that format's long been lost, since the advent of the hot guys who sing cute. Argh!
kathleen cox
May 18th, 2012 8:02 AM
I agree with "cwalt" the judges seemed to be choosing Joshua from the onset. I spoke up about it online. If you cannot give all the attention they deserve, then sit yo arse down and clap. I felt all along that Joshua and Jessica only shouted, more than they sang. Phillip may change up a "melody" but how refreshing was that? I don't want to hear a rendition of a song that sounds just like the original, I agree with Simon Cowell on that.So, I am pleased with the results from last nite.
cwalt
May 18th, 2012 7:38 AM
For you people the are disappointed about joshua being voted off, ask your self this, he never sang a song that wasn't gospel, church and usually had at least 6-8 back up singers. bottom line I think he can sing well but only for what's listed above he's got NOTHING else and his sound is from a time that's gone and will never be back. he has no where to go ask yourselves what would his album sound like. he can't be marketed. something I found just so crazy and sad is this year the show was about race with the judges? Does a black person have to win this year because its been some time since a person of color has won? I've never seen anything so one sided the judges stood up and clapped for the last 6+ weeks for almost every song some justified but so many very clearly not at all. Never stood up for hardly anyone else it's a joke. Again, as I said he is a bad ass but only at the church gospel thing that he can perform with a little outdated R&B so, he needed to go. It appeared as
Carmen
May 18th, 2012 7:13 AM
Congratulations to the finalists, however I feel that it would have been a real treat for Joshua and Jessica to battle it out, as they are the ones with the talent. Phillip is easy to listen to but Joshua is in a class of his own. Being in my sixtees I feel he brings back the sound of the greats.Joshua you are the idol in my books, but your composure and dignity in accepting the results make you even better. Cheers and good luck for the future from Carmen in Queensland Australia
May 21st, 2012 4:59 PM
P2????Are you kiddin' me?It's JESSICA ALL OVER THE WORLD..PEOPLE VOTE FOR JESSICA for the win...
May 21st, 2012 4:56 PM
JESSICA FOR THE WIN!!!
May 21st, 2012 4:55 PM
JESSICA FTW!!Big NO to P2..
May 21st, 2012 12:08 AM
Consider it done Jessica won first week albums sales over 1 million copies. Jessica is an awesome Chinese American who has won are hearts.
May 19th, 2012 11:40 PM
Joshua's version of Imagine was a disaster. That scared cow of a song should not be done unless you understand the song's message. Joshua over sang the song, which he does to all songs, but, the simplicity and purity of the song's message was buried under Josh's overly dramatic performance. It is almost criminal what he did to that song.
May 19th, 2012 10:24 AM
Get over it if your favorite idol contestant did not make the finale. Both Jessica and Philip are in the finale simply because more fans voted for them . Although winning AI is one big achievement and a stepping stone for a future music career we all know by now that post idol it does not guarantee the winner a successful music career. If you truly believe in the talent of your endeared idol contestant continue to support him/her post idol. That is where your genuine support will truly matter.
May 18th, 2012 9:17 PM
@ Robert D, don't they all impersonate? don't they all sing songs not theirs? they are all copy cats, not only jessica, not only joshua not only philip but the rest of AI singers. Couldn't be helped! IT IS WHAT IT IS
May 18th, 2012 8:22 PM
As much as I didn't want it to happen, I knew Joshua was next to go. He will have more success than all of the other contestants put together--I hope producers don't "Usher" him up and put him in videos with half-naked girls--if there was still a Motown, he would be the next Motown Icon--he is amazing. Jessica and Philip are, in my opinion, one trick ponies--as a matter of fact they bore me. I won't be watching next week--the show will be a yawner. I agree. I can picture Jessica in front of her mirror with a hair brush, mimicing Whitney, etal--and she is too young to be in the show. Phil will win--all of the teenage girls will vote for him.
Rank: Regular Character
May 18th, 2012 5:43 PM
You know I've just set here and read ALL these comments.
All of you hollering "I'm not watching AI anymore" ........no doubt you'll watch the finale next week.........
I do think Jessica should have went home. And the main reason is she is just too young. I don't feel 16 year olds should be on the show and subjected to that kind of pressure. She can sing yes, but to me it's just imitations of the originals and she needs more time to grown.
Joshua can sing as well and I feel that he's going to be fine. He needs to prove that he can move away from gospel (in other words, BE MORE VERSITLE) and the 10 backup singers and the screaming.
I am still pulling for Phillip to win it. It is of no consequence to me that a girl hasn't won in several years.
Rank: Recurring Character
May 18th, 2012 5:18 PM
At least the top 2 aren't two dudes like 3 years ago...
May 18th, 2012 2:50 PM
To Janie Juser, I just hpoe you are really a gorgeous beyond belief woman because if I have to guess your personality based on your shameful out of line comments you are one ugly , evil spirited creature reeked with odor that comes from all the feces of human and animals. Why on earth you would comment about Jessica's teeth when we are talking about singing competition. My guess is you can not criticize her singing that is credible.
May 18th, 2012 12:04 PM
You can have Jessica, BORING!!!!!!, too bad about Joshua, love PP, mostly 'cause the judges don't & he sticks to who he is!!!!
May 18th, 2012 11:45 AM
Joshua deserved to be in the finale with Philip. I'm sad he left but I think it's a good thing, he won't be tied to the AI machine and he can carve out a career for himself. Right now I don't care who wins but if I must choose i would prefer Philip to win just because I believe Jessica still has some growing up to do. There's something that puts me off pageant stiff way of singing. Somehow I think she will win it all for two reasons (1) It's time a woman (girl) won (2) The filipino's are treating it like the second coming (including their President).
May 18th, 2012 11:35 AM
Continued: I would like to have seen all three of them sing the same song. They could have done a recorded version. Joshua's back ground is gospel, i rarely go to church, but when has it ever been wrong to do so. He was not screaming. He was hitting notes. Something Phillips can't do. Phillips was straining just to hold a note on his last song. America go it Wrong and Idol is rigged. No more Idol for me. Tired of it all.
May 18th, 2012 11:18 AM
Joshua could flat out sing. He put pashion and sould into his music and performances. You made a point, Joshua is not marketable if possibly compared to Phillips because of his stle of music and demographics. Phillips songs did not have any type of techinical difficulty. Although I like him and he performances were relaxed, he cannot hold at note and the way he rounded notes were predictable and evident he cannot sing. He talked his songs. His voice has good tone, but that's it. They made Phillips seems has if he was in the bottom two, when he might have been in the top two last week. They did the same thing last night. They potrayed Jessica as she was ahead on votes, but honestly Phillips could have been. I did not think the true winner would win because demographics plays and important role. Joshua left it out there every time and all of his performance were nice. Phillips is mediocre and you can find people all over the south and other select parts of the country doing the same sty
Rank: Recurring Character
May 18th, 2012 10:46 AM
i think philip philips is just like david cook...and kris allen...and lee dwyze. pretty boy semi-rocker dudes with a guitar. and where are they now? we have too many guys like philip already. as for jessica, i think she can be a true diva. and she can also be a fashion icon and trendsetter.
May 18th, 2012 10:27 AM
Jessica sounded awful on Wednesday who said artist want to sign her ?? Honestly most artist hate American idol cause they think these guys are over privileged when they had to work so hard to get to where they are today in other word these guys haven't paid there dues. And the judges gave standing o's to Joshua cause he's good ..do u guys not remember Jessica was already voted off ? Then the judges got up there and said she is onE of the best singers in the world ? Lol really? haha the most successful at to come out of ai in last 5 years is Adam Lambert and u saw just how great he was last night right? Everyone else is pretty much no where or soon to be dropped for there labels . We just can't pick em let the music business do there jobs and find talent on there own cancel shows like this it creates a bad image for music
Rank: New User
May 18th, 2012 10:11 AM
Jessica will win because not just Americans are voting. Mexicans and Phillipinos around the world are voting also with Magic Jack and computers.
May 18th, 2012 9:45 AM
PLEASE I mean really....please get rid of Jessica at the finale...I cannot stand to look at those teeth hanging out when she sings!!!!! GO PHILLIP PHILLIPS!!!!!!
May 18th, 2012 9:35 AM
Well what father welcomes his son home with a gun attached to his pants Think Phillip Phillips .Such a shame America that the real Singer has been eliminated.I guess gun culture is really alive and well spirituality (Joshua ) vs (redneck) guns America no wonder Joshua felt relieved to be leaving who wants to be aligned with that energy shame on you Phillip Phillips Snr even Ryan Seacrest pointed it out .Time to vote Joshua back in .
May 18th, 2012 9:16 AM
Why isn't Phillip in any of the Ford videos?
May 18th, 2012 8:57 AM
Yes, I know Phil's gonna win. But here's hoping I'm wrong on this one... It's been a while since we have a female actually worthy of winning American Idol. I think Lauren from last year didn't have that, so I'm not surprised to see Scotty eventually win it. But Jessica, she's just too good to not win. And if we really look back, American Idol used to be a singing competition - so basically the title should go to the best singer. But that format's long been lost, since the advent of the hot guys who sing cute. Argh!
May 18th, 2012 8:02 AM
I agree with "cwalt" the judges seemed to be choosing Joshua from the onset. I spoke up about it online. If you cannot give all the attention they deserve, then sit yo arse down and clap. I felt all along that Joshua and Jessica only shouted, more than they sang. Phillip may change up a "melody" but how refreshing was that? I don't want to hear a rendition of a song that sounds just like the original, I agree with Simon Cowell on that.So, I am pleased with the results from last nite.
May 18th, 2012 7:38 AM
For you people the are disappointed about joshua being voted off, ask your self this, he never sang a song that wasn't gospel, church and usually had at least 6-8 back up singers. bottom line I think he can sing well but only for what's listed above he's got NOTHING else and his sound is from a time that's gone and will never be back. he has no where to go ask yourselves what would his album sound like. he can't be marketed. something I found just so crazy and sad is this year the show was about race with the judges? Does a black person have to win this year because its been some time since a person of color has won? I've never seen anything so one sided the judges stood up and clapped for the last 6+ weeks for almost every song some justified but so many very clearly not at all. Never stood up for hardly anyone else it's a joke. Again, as I said he is a bad ass but only at the church gospel thing that he can perform with a little outdated R&B so, he needed to go. It appeared as
May 18th, 2012 7:13 AM
Congratulations to the finalists, however I feel that it would have been a real treat for Joshua and Jessica to battle it out, as they are the ones with the talent. Phillip is easy to listen to but Joshua is in a class of his own. Being in my sixtees I feel he brings back the sound of the greats.Joshua you are the idol in my books, but your composure and dignity in accepting the results make you even better. Cheers and good luck for the future from Carmen in Queensland Australia