American Idol Results: The Fabulous 4 Comments (Page 3)
57 Comments
nixie supermodel
May 4th, 2012 12:52 AM
Skylar went home coz America did not bother to vote for her. Well Im glad she went home. Skylar is really great with country music, she basically sings all songs the same…like country songs. Dont get me wrong, I like her but since this is a competition, one has to go home. Jessica has an amazing voice and such maturity for a 16 year old. Joshua sound great as well except that it becomes irritating to my ears every time he screams when he sings and doing his artsy stuff that he sounds like an old woman who i dont know is crying or arguing. I would like to hear joshua sing straight for once so that we can really determine the quality of his voice singing and not screaming. Philips..well he is passable..he is just a good entertainer but nothing really outstanding with his voice..dunno why he’s still in the show..probably a lot of women and teens voting for his looks rather than his voice. I could say the same for hollie who looks like a doll but this one also has a great voice only th
Phil
May 4th, 2012 12:42 AM
I can't believe Phillips is STILL hanging on. I don't know how he got into the final group let alone last this long?? Then the judges keep saying how original his singing and "dancing" are. I guess they never saw Dave Matthews perform? Each season I believe more and more, they do whatever they want to with the results to add drama to the show. If people are actually voting as indicated, well, what can I say? I also think all of these type shows should allow only ONE vote per person. What does it prove if one person can vote a thousand times??? I'm through watching this show. There has been much too much BS going on the past few years.
Marilyn
May 4th, 2012 12:39 AM
Although I love all of the remainding four singers, my favorite is Hollie. She's the whole package ~ a true talent and entertainer. She's amazing!
Miranda Wicker Rank: Staff Member
May 4th, 2012 12:21 AM
@xmeg--I did catch that, and I tried to piece together what Jimmy meant. Now that you've commented, yes, Phillip has been sick during this competition. I know they've talked about kidney stones and how he's fought them during the season. Perhaps he's sicker than they've let on and he's asked them not to discuss it, or the producers have asked Ryan not to talk about it? Just grasping at reasons here, but yes, he has had some illness.
love me
May 4th, 2012 12:17 AM
Hollie technically is the only girl to never be voted off Jessica has Hollie us the leader of the pack people got it all wrong whose getting sympathy votes cause she was voted off Jessica is a little girl with a flashy voice I just don't believe her I'm sorry I disconnect when she performs u think hands down joshua will win he's a little hard to connect with as well...I think we all connect with Hollie cause always in the bottom and counted out that connects a lot of peeps to pull for her cause we all are fighters way to go Hollie keep improving.
mccoy
May 4th, 2012 12:04 AM
what a waste of time reading...obviously u hate jessica which means u have no ear for voice and have no taste for music. ur site will crumble soon
Donovan
May 3rd, 2012 11:48 PM
I didn't like Colton and I like Phillip even less. I love Joshua. Great voice. Great showmanship. Jessica has a great voice and when she hit that high note, it was unreal it was so beautiful. Hollie is a great singer but there's just something that turns me off about her. I would buy CDs by Jessica and Joshua. Only.
Brian SAMLALSINGH
May 3rd, 2012 11:36 PM
jESSICA IS BY FAR THE BEST SONGSTRESS AND PHILLIP IS THE WORST....HOW IS HE STILL THERE I WILL NEVER KNOW.
HE IS GOO9D LOOKING BUT IS SOMEWHAT CRUDE IN ATTITUDE AND SPEECH...HE NEEDS LESSONS IN DRESSING...BUT IS APPEALING TO THE AMERICAN PUBLIC. HOWEVER HE IS NOT DESERVING TO BE IN THE TOP FOUR O9R FIVE....MAYBE SIXTH.
Connie
May 3rd, 2012 11:07 PM
This is totally reminiscent of the last season of X-Factor when they sent Melanie Amaro home and then brought her back to take the win. I think they are doing the same and that this contest is fixed. I knew Jessica would win the minute the judges saved her. She is a great singer like Pia Toscano but is so predictable and boring. Honestly how many of you have bought a Pia albumor would buy Jessica's album? Skylar should have made top three at least.
Rover
May 3rd, 2012 10:53 PM
I wonder if they'll do a bottom 2 next week. If they do and Hollie is in it, and stays, she will have had the most Bottom 3/2 appearances than any contestant in Idol history. I'm proud of how far Hollie has come. If she goes she goes. But that doesn't mean anything in the entertainment industry wise. She'll also have a tough journey outside of Idol, but that comes as it is. It's about having the right material and the right promotion!
Nathan
May 3rd, 2012 10:45 PM
America or the producers can put Hollie in the bottom two all they want. But as long as she stays in the competition I'll be fine! I'll be voting even harder for Hollie to stay. Perfect under dog story. I felt as though a majority of Colton's fans voted for Hollie to stay. And then a majority of Elise's fans voted for Hollie to stay. And Now I feel as though a Big Majority of Skylar's fans will vote for Hollie to stay. Basically a vote transfer. But we'll see
Robert
May 3rd, 2012 10:39 PM
Hollie has the best voice. She may have some growing to do to perfect her art, but she has the best and easiest sound to her voice. I buy all the Idol music and when you listen to all the contestants sing, Hollie has the best sound and tone to her voice. She deserves to win or have a huge career. Jessica does not have a pleasant sound to her voice. Sure she can sing well, but it is not the sound that I like to hear. A crow can crow well, but I don't want to listen to it. Get what I mean? Phillip is good but a little goes a long way lately. Joshua is another talented singer, but I personally do not like listening to his crying sound when he sings. Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa. Skylar, is a true winner as a singer, performer and a person. She is very likable!
I am rooting for Hollie a 100% Please pack your bags, Jessica! I had enough of you!
xmeg816x
May 3rd, 2012 10:35 PM
@luis tad, I don't understand your comment about w howard having racial discrimination. If he was supposedly discriminating based on race he would have listed hollie instead of josh don't you think? Its just plain rude to acuse someone of discrimination.
Ok now back to the actual reason I wanted to comment...
Did any one catch what Jimmy said about Phillip. About if anyone else was feeling like Phillip has been feeling they would have given up...and last week he was talking about Phillip not feeling well. Is he sick or something? This is the second time Jimmy has mentioned something yet Ryan never says anything to Phillip about it afterwards which is very unlike Ryan. If its sickness then well wow he has been sick for couple weeks now. Idk strange but it would explain a lot because Phillip has seemed a little unPhillip like as of late.
I'm super upset, skylar was my fave other than elise... Here's to hoping that Phillip finally gets eliminated and we have a Hollie & Joshua finale....
dante
May 3rd, 2012 10:25 PM
These Idol judges are the worst of any season ... silly comments.
Jimmy is the only intelligent input. I don't always agree with his viewpoint, but I respect him. I have to tape the show so I can fast forward thru Jennifer and Steven.
Ms. Romanoff
May 3rd, 2012 10:24 PM
I am just so happy that Skylar Laine went home. I don't know with you guys but, It's about time. :)
Rev John
May 3rd, 2012 10:09 PM
As a Senior Idol fan I am taken back to Elvis Presley. They said he could not sing, but was handsome, gave good hip action and we all know that through the years his stage presence grew. So while Philip may not be the best singer, America sees and hears something they like. The Judges may have anointed Joshua or perhaps Jessica, but what if it turns out Hollie and Philip are the last two standing...now that would be America with a thumbs down to the three judges. They seem who more biased this year than ever.
Eileen Cooper
May 3rd, 2012 10:00 PM
I have no idea who the majority voting are,but Skylar was not the one to be voted off tonight!!I will miss her spunk and the refreshment she brought to the show!
Based on last night's performance,if that is how people voted,Philip should have gone home!
I live in Canada and wish I could vote!I DO watch the show!!!!
I feel Jimmy has a more professional critique than any of the judges!
Miss Simon.s often misunderstood criticism,but he at least said what he felt was valid and didn't hold back and I feel that made the contestants try harder and push themselves to the limit!
Love all the judges,but they are too non critical,and don't push them to their max!
I am still curious about last nights comment that Joshua is the best artist(I believe it was Jennifer who said that)in the last 50 years!!That was an unbelievable comment!Who is the other person?
Very unhappy about tonight,s elimination!!
The weirdest season yet for judges guidance!!!Jimmy is like Simon!he calls it as he sees it!
shari
May 3rd, 2012 9:54 PM
Joshua has the IDOL VOICE
luis tad
May 3rd, 2012 9:50 PM
w howard, you just shown ur racial discrimination. the travesty is that we voted and skylar was the least vote getter. she deserves to be booted out. ur the joke w howard....what a shame..
w howard
May 3rd, 2012 9:33 PM
What a travesty....the wrong fin al 4! Should be Colton, Skylar, Josh and Phil! Thanks for screwing this one up Jennifer....what a joke you are!
Jessica Fan!
May 3rd, 2012 9:26 PM
Keep it going Jessica! The city of San Diego and Chula Vista are behind you!
May 4th, 2012 12:52 AM
Skylar went home coz America did not bother to vote for her. Well Im glad she went home. Skylar is really great with country music, she basically sings all songs the same…like country songs. Dont get me wrong, I like her but since this is a competition, one has to go home. Jessica has an amazing voice and such maturity for a 16 year old. Joshua sound great as well except that it becomes irritating to my ears every time he screams when he sings and doing his artsy stuff that he sounds like an old woman who i dont know is crying or arguing. I would like to hear joshua sing straight for once so that we can really determine the quality of his voice singing and not screaming. Philips..well he is passable..he is just a good entertainer but nothing really outstanding with his voice..dunno why he’s still in the show..probably a lot of women and teens voting for his looks rather than his voice. I could say the same for hollie who looks like a doll but this one also has a great voice only th
May 4th, 2012 12:42 AM
I can't believe Phillips is STILL hanging on. I don't know how he got into the final group let alone last this long?? Then the judges keep saying how original his singing and "dancing" are. I guess they never saw Dave Matthews perform? Each season I believe more and more, they do whatever they want to with the results to add drama to the show. If people are actually voting as indicated, well, what can I say? I also think all of these type shows should allow only ONE vote per person. What does it prove if one person can vote a thousand times??? I'm through watching this show. There has been much too much BS going on the past few years.
May 4th, 2012 12:39 AM
Although I love all of the remainding four singers, my favorite is Hollie. She's the whole package ~ a true talent and entertainer. She's amazing!
Rank: Staff Member
May 4th, 2012 12:21 AM
@xmeg--I did catch that, and I tried to piece together what Jimmy meant. Now that you've commented, yes, Phillip has been sick during this competition. I know they've talked about kidney stones and how he's fought them during the season. Perhaps he's sicker than they've let on and he's asked them not to discuss it, or the producers have asked Ryan not to talk about it? Just grasping at reasons here, but yes, he has had some illness.
May 4th, 2012 12:17 AM
Hollie technically is the only girl to never be voted off Jessica has Hollie us the leader of the pack people got it all wrong whose getting sympathy votes cause she was voted off Jessica is a little girl with a flashy voice I just don't believe her I'm sorry I disconnect when she performs u think hands down joshua will win he's a little hard to connect with as well...I think we all connect with Hollie cause always in the bottom and counted out that connects a lot of peeps to pull for her cause we all are fighters way to go Hollie keep improving.
May 4th, 2012 12:04 AM
what a waste of time reading...obviously u hate jessica which means u have no ear for voice and have no taste for music. ur site will crumble soon
May 3rd, 2012 11:48 PM
I didn't like Colton and I like Phillip even less. I love Joshua. Great voice. Great showmanship. Jessica has a great voice and when she hit that high note, it was unreal it was so beautiful. Hollie is a great singer but there's just something that turns me off about her. I would buy CDs by Jessica and Joshua. Only.
May 3rd, 2012 11:36 PM
jESSICA IS BY FAR THE BEST SONGSTRESS AND PHILLIP IS THE WORST....HOW IS HE STILL THERE I WILL NEVER KNOW.
HE IS GOO9D LOOKING BUT IS SOMEWHAT CRUDE IN ATTITUDE AND SPEECH...HE NEEDS LESSONS IN DRESSING...BUT IS APPEALING TO THE AMERICAN PUBLIC. HOWEVER HE IS NOT DESERVING TO BE IN THE TOP FOUR O9R FIVE....MAYBE SIXTH.
May 3rd, 2012 11:07 PM
This is totally reminiscent of the last season of X-Factor when they sent Melanie Amaro home and then brought her back to take the win. I think they are doing the same and that this contest is fixed. I knew Jessica would win the minute the judges saved her. She is a great singer like Pia Toscano but is so predictable and boring. Honestly how many of you have bought a Pia albumor would buy Jessica's album? Skylar should have made top three at least.
May 3rd, 2012 10:53 PM
I wonder if they'll do a bottom 2 next week. If they do and Hollie is in it, and stays, she will have had the most Bottom 3/2 appearances than any contestant in Idol history. I'm proud of how far Hollie has come. If she goes she goes. But that doesn't mean anything in the entertainment industry wise. She'll also have a tough journey outside of Idol, but that comes as it is. It's about having the right material and the right promotion!
May 3rd, 2012 10:45 PM
America or the producers can put Hollie in the bottom two all they want. But as long as she stays in the competition I'll be fine! I'll be voting even harder for Hollie to stay. Perfect under dog story. I felt as though a majority of Colton's fans voted for Hollie to stay. And then a majority of Elise's fans voted for Hollie to stay. And Now I feel as though a Big Majority of Skylar's fans will vote for Hollie to stay. Basically a vote transfer. But we'll see
May 3rd, 2012 10:39 PM
Hollie has the best voice. She may have some growing to do to perfect her art, but she has the best and easiest sound to her voice. I buy all the Idol music and when you listen to all the contestants sing, Hollie has the best sound and tone to her voice. She deserves to win or have a huge career. Jessica does not have a pleasant sound to her voice. Sure she can sing well, but it is not the sound that I like to hear. A crow can crow well, but I don't want to listen to it. Get what I mean? Phillip is good but a little goes a long way lately. Joshua is another talented singer, but I personally do not like listening to his crying sound when he sings. Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa. Skylar, is a true winner as a singer, performer and a person. She is very likable!
I am rooting for Hollie a 100% Please pack your bags, Jessica! I had enough of you!
May 3rd, 2012 10:35 PM
@luis tad, I don't understand your comment about w howard having racial discrimination. If he was supposedly discriminating based on race he would have listed hollie instead of josh don't you think? Its just plain rude to acuse someone of discrimination.
Ok now back to the actual reason I wanted to comment...
Did any one catch what Jimmy said about Phillip. About if anyone else was feeling like Phillip has been feeling they would have given up...and last week he was talking about Phillip not feeling well. Is he sick or something? This is the second time Jimmy has mentioned something yet Ryan never says anything to Phillip about it afterwards which is very unlike Ryan. If its sickness then well wow he has been sick for couple weeks now. Idk strange but it would explain a lot because Phillip has seemed a little unPhillip like as of late.
Rank: Guest Star
May 3rd, 2012 10:31 PM
I'm super upset, skylar was my fave other than elise... Here's to hoping that Phillip finally gets eliminated and we have a Hollie & Joshua finale....
May 3rd, 2012 10:25 PM
These Idol judges are the worst of any season ... silly comments.
Jimmy is the only intelligent input. I don't always agree with his viewpoint, but I respect him. I have to tape the show so I can fast forward thru Jennifer and Steven.
May 3rd, 2012 10:24 PM
I am just so happy that Skylar Laine went home. I don't know with you guys but, It's about time. :)
May 3rd, 2012 10:09 PM
As a Senior Idol fan I am taken back to Elvis Presley. They said he could not sing, but was handsome, gave good hip action and we all know that through the years his stage presence grew. So while Philip may not be the best singer, America sees and hears something they like. The Judges may have anointed Joshua or perhaps Jessica, but what if it turns out Hollie and Philip are the last two standing...now that would be America with a thumbs down to the three judges. They seem who more biased this year than ever.
May 3rd, 2012 10:00 PM
I have no idea who the majority voting are,but Skylar was not the one to be voted off tonight!!I will miss her spunk and the refreshment she brought to the show!
Based on last night's performance,if that is how people voted,Philip should have gone home!
I live in Canada and wish I could vote!I DO watch the show!!!!
I feel Jimmy has a more professional critique than any of the judges!
Miss Simon.s often misunderstood criticism,but he at least said what he felt was valid and didn't hold back and I feel that made the contestants try harder and push themselves to the limit!
Love all the judges,but they are too non critical,and don't push them to their max!
I am still curious about last nights comment that Joshua is the best artist(I believe it was Jennifer who said that)in the last 50 years!!That was an unbelievable comment!Who is the other person?
Very unhappy about tonight,s elimination!!
The weirdest season yet for judges guidance!!!Jimmy is like Simon!he calls it as he sees it!
May 3rd, 2012 9:54 PM
Joshua has the IDOL VOICE
May 3rd, 2012 9:50 PM
w howard, you just shown ur racial discrimination. the travesty is that we voted and skylar was the least vote getter. she deserves to be booted out. ur the joke w howard....what a shame..
May 3rd, 2012 9:33 PM
What a travesty....the wrong fin al 4! Should be Colton, Skylar, Josh and Phil! Thanks for screwing this one up Jennifer....what a joke you are!
May 3rd, 2012 9:26 PM
Keep it going Jessica! The city of San Diego and Chula Vista are behind you!