Glee Review: From Past to Prologue

at . Comments

Glee went back to 1977 on "Saturday Night Glee-ver," paying homage to the film that made John Travola, white suits and spinning disco balls famous.

But the episode really used the past to pen a prologue for three key seniors, as Finn, Santana and Mercedes made major decisions regarding their future. Each has a much clearer idea now of what it will bring.

Dancing in the Hall

When season three started, it appeared as if Glee would tackle the daunting challenge of senior year, of truly figuring out what one wants to do with one's life. But somewhere between tribute episodes, Christmas specials and car accidents, that theme got lost. Until tonight.

I was mostly pleased with how it was handled, with the exception of the same complaint I make every week in this space: the random nature of storylines and the lack of character development. Take Mercedes, for example.

As she delivered her inner monologue, along with a great version of "Disco Inferno," I put on my Carrie Bradshow hat and couldn't help but wonder...

What do we know about her outside the choir room? What hobbies does she possess? What class does she excel in? Were you aware her father was a dentist (what an arbitrary throw-in, too: why wouldn't a dentist support a singing career?) before that nugget was dropped?

I also thought back to how Mr. Schuester described the trio of seniors featured - Finn as talented, but lacking self-esteem; Mercedes as lacking vision; Santana as lacking focus - and thought: really? Are those descriptions truly apt? Or did the writers toss them in just to fit this episode, this motif.

I'm sorry, but Finn doesn't really possess talent, not when compared with other club members. Going to acting school is perfect for him, Rachel believes? Does anyone else believe this? How does that, in any way, jibe with what we know about Finn Hudson? Except to give the writers material for season four?

And Mercedes without vision? She seemed to lack confidence more than vision here, and even that didn't seem consistent: since when does Mercedes Jones need an ego boost?!? This is one strong young diva who has always asked for more time in the spotlight.

That video Sam made was nice and all, but it only seemed necessary because Glee chose to shape Mercedes in a certain manner, for one week only, to make this storyline work.

And Santana received a full cheerleading scholarship? I mean, did she even apply to Louisville?!? Where did that come from? And what the heck have you been doing, Emma Pillsbury? Please spend less time cleaning grapes and more time acting like an actual guidance counselor for next year's class. These kids need you more than three weeks prior to graduation!

(Or not, I suppose, when magic scholarships and acting studio acceptances appear out of nowhere. For shame, James Lipton.)

The sad truth is that most of these characters - Mercedes, Brittany, Santana, Quinn (who, ummm, I guess was taking wheelchair lessons somewhere else?), Artie, Mike, Tina, Puck - stopped being human beings ages ago. They were turned into mechanisms through which the show could sell tracks on iTunes - there was A LOT of Glee music this week - or deliver Public Service Announcements.

And that's depressing, isn't it? It's almost anger-inducing. We've sat and watched the show for nearly three seasons and, just as many students are about to graduate and we're asked to feel something about them, we're left asking: wait, who are these people?!? What can we say about them outside of the nauseating assignments Will doles out each week?

(Perform a song from Saturday Night Fever and then share your hopes for the future. He actually said that. He also said: It's not the broken dreams that break us. It's the ones we don't dare to dream. I really hope Matthew Morrison at least had trouble getting these words out.)

Yes, I know: it's a musical. What am I doing asking for less music? But that's my point: I wish the show had strived for more as a whole. I wish it had used music as a way to more fully develop well-rounded characters (or just to be fun!), not as the sole way in which we know the characters.

And not just as their sole hope for the future. I'd love to have seen Mercedes acknowledge that she loves singing, she'll always include it in her life... but you know what? She's gonna strive to be an architect! Or perhaps a nurse or an interior designer. The arts are great, but making a career out of them is next to impossible and also - as much as it would pain Glee to admit - it's perfectly okay to plan on a more realistic, attainable major or profession.

That doesn't mean you don't have dreams. It just means you're growing up.

All that said, the episode in and of itself was fine overall. But it simply served to remind me of all Glee could have been if it dedicated an entire season to the journey of these seniors, not slapped most of it together faster than Will and Sue slapped together the concept of a Saturday Night Fever tribute.

I will, however, leave you with a few of the best Glee quotes from the week, as Sue and Brittany were especially on fire. I'll also ask: What did everyone else think? Do you feel like you know these seniors well?

Sue: Her chagrin is limited only by the fact that she has a brain the size of a toddler's fist.
Brittany: I can show you the MRI. | permalink
Brittany [on a bull's testicle]: It tastes just like a chicken testicle. | permalink
Puck: Two dudes in one bed is, like, confirmed gay. | permalink
Sue: Let's be honest, William. You've been out of ideas since Madonna week. | permalink
Rachel: While we applaud your proper use of the terminology, but we told Mr. Schue: we do not support disco. | permalink


Editor Rating: 3.4 / 5.0
  • 3.4 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 3.4 / 5.0 (196 Votes)

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.


@bobby Try and quote me specifically saying do not say anything, I NEVER did. I stated that people who are so upset with others expressing an alternate opinion (whether they are in the 'love Glee' camp or 'loathe Glee' camp) should reconsider entering into discussion with such people, that does not mean I think they should shut up. It merely means if something upsets you so much why do you do it? If I was going to tell anyone to shut up I'd do it directly.
Go ahead and keep expressing your desire for people who have negative opinions of the show to not mention them here, feel free I am in no way telling you to be quiet. But don't tell me I told anyone to shut up. I merely said if something upsets you you MIGHT want to reconsider involving yourself in it.


@tootz look at everything that u said to me and tell me if u still think u didn't want me to express my thoughts..and those who like the whole episode and have nothing bad to say about it shouldn't be told to "shutup" and like u said I quote "everyone should be allowed to say what they want and if they cant handle people disagreeing then don't enter into the conversation with people simple. Follow your own advice.


love glee but i dont think that finchel is right and if quartie doent happen come on faberevans


bring on the quartie!!!!!!!!!!! and i think quinn should stay and help and stay with artie


@bobby I NEVER said people shouldn't express their thoughts on the show. Far from it.
Some people are going to love the show and they are well within their right to express that, but those who point out what they disliked shouldn't be told to shut up and just enjoy it anyway (which is what YOU did!) and I quote "Why can't people just enjoy the episode don't think to much into all the time always have to say negative things".
It seems to be the people who think the show is amazing and flawless are the ones who tell those more realistic about the shows limitations to not express their opinions not the other way round. Everyone should be allowed to say what they want and if they can't handle people disagreeing then don't enter into conversation with people! Simple!


I don't know if anyone's answered your question yet, but NPH played a character during a Season 1 episode called "Dream On" which was directed by Joss Whedon.


I missed Matt last week!!! That Carla Girl didn't really give constructive criticism. NEVER LEAVE AGAIN MATT!!


I completely agree with you Matt! If you want a reviewer that's going to love it and never criticize it, THAT'S NOT A REVIEW. If you want the reviewer to review it like a fun entertainment show then glee should consistently do that. Glee changes it up too much; some heartfelt, others funny and throw in stupidity everywhere and that's what this season was all about...


Enjoyed Alex Newell's first appearance very much! The As the review said, too much just slapped together. Also, Quinn was very conspicuously absent considering she just had a huge storyline centered on her. And of course, since when is Finn an actor? Also, is Rory gone from the show now, or was he also simply very absent?


Since when did Finn ever want to be an actor??? When did Santana put in an application for a scholarship??? Too many WTFs in this show that I've given up trying to make sense of any of it. I totally agree with the reviewer. This show has completely become one big video hits of remakes. The only thing it is serving are the original artists as it is bringing new listeners to their music. The show however is a complete waste. There is no plot whatsoever and the characters have become one dimensional. Every week it is either a tribute and/or PSA that doesn't even fit any plot or characters.

Tags: ,

Glee Season 3 Episode 16 Quotes

Santana: Blaine's handsome brother said it best: college is a waste of time. I just wanna be famous, plain and simple.

Let's be honest, William. You've been out of ideas since Madonna week.


Glee Season 3 Episode 16 Music

  Song Artist
Glee cast if i cant have you If I Can't Have You Glee Cast iTunes
Glee cast more than a woman More Than a Woman Glee Cast iTunes
Glee cast you should be dancing You Should Be Dancing Glee Cast iTunes