American Idol

Tuesdays 8:00 PM on FOX
American idol
TV Fanatic Works Better with Prime Instant Video
40,000 other titles are available to watch now.

American Idol Results: A Shocking Save

by at . Comments

Last night the American Idol Top 7 performed songs released in the past two years. This "theme" was a good one because it allowed some of the contestants to show what kind of artist they'd be if they released a record right now. But last night wasn't a great night for everyone.

Let's hear what our pal Jimmy had to say about last night's show and find out who, if anyone, will be leaving. Remember, the judges still have a save in play for at least two more weeks.

A Startling Bottom Three

Before we get any results, we get what may be the most awkward group sing in the history of Idol. They're all singing Pink's "Raise Your Glass." And dancing. Awkwardly. Idol, this isn't Glee. They've done this already, and they did it better. TV Fanatic commenters called you out on it last night and I'm calling you out on this insanity right now. Stop this nonsense.

Hollie Cavanagh and Jessica Sanchez hit the floor first. Jimmy starts by complimenting both girls on their technical abilities, but says Hollie's performance was "contrived and stiff" and Jessica, hands down, won the night between the two girls. Jimmy's correct on both accounts. Hollie can't get out of her own head and Jessica is clearly the better performer.

Hollie's told to start a group on the right side of the stage. Jessica starts a group on the left.

Tonight's the night where they'll ask the seventh and final person to choose which group is the bottom three and which group is the top four. This night always puts the seventh contestant in an awkward place, if you ask me, and I've never been more proud than when David Archuleta decided to just sit down in the middle of the stage and NOT choose a group.

Idol alum James Durbin is back tonight performing the upcoming single "Higher Than Heaven" from his debut album. He's changed his hair and looks like a slim Guy Fieri. My only comment is about his appearance, so that should tell you what I think about his performance.

Up next, Elise Testone and Phillip Phillips take the stage. Jimmy says they're both singer-songwriters, without the songs, which makes them character singers and not technical singers. He comments on Phillip's heavy Dave Matthews Band influence in last night's Maroon 5 number and thinks Phillip could find himself in the bottom three. As for Elise, Jimmy didn't think she did enough. Jimmy's correct in one regard--these two are definitely suited for the singer-songwriter genre. Until we can hear Phillip perform his own songs, we'll hear Phillip perform the songs of others in his own signature way. The same goes for Elise, though I'd counter Jimmy in that she CAN be a technical singer when she needs to be.

Ryan sends Phillip to stand with Hollie and Elise to stand with Jessica. And now I'm a little nervous.

Another Idol alum, Jennifer Hudson, performs "Think Like A Man" with Ne-Yo. Her performance is maybe the best guest performance we've seen all season, but I expect nothing less from someone as talented and driven as she is.

Colton Dixon, Joshua Ledet, and Skylar Laine remain. Joshua and Colton head to Ryan's podium. Jimmy says they both did well last night, and Joshua's performance was a perfect, contemporary song. Colton, he says, is a singer-songwriter without the song (not unlike Elise and Phillip). Last night was a good night for Joshua because it made him relevant. Colton's known since he got into this who he wants to be and what kind of records he wants to make. Jimmy, once again, is correct about both guys.

Joshua is sent to stand in the group with Jessica and Elise. Colton joins Hollie and Phillip.

So now it's Skylar's turn to hear her critique from Jimmy. Jimmy calls Skylar a singer-songwriter AND a technical singer and thinks Skylar had one of the best performances of the night. Jimmy and I differ in our thoughts about Skylar. I don't think she's a particularly technical singer. I think she's a talented country singer, but I don't think she's very technical. At least not in the way that Jessica is and Hollie can be.

Ryan tells Skylar she's safe and cells her to choose the group she thinks is safe. She refuses and heads to the couch. (Atta girl, Skylar!) And then Ryan puts her in the group with Hollie, Phillip, and Colton. Which means the four of them are safe.

Jessica, Joshua, and Elise are in the bottom three. And my mouth is hanging open. Before any of them can even be declared the eliminated contestant, Steven vows that the judges will be using their save tonight with no question.

Joshua is sent back to the couches leaving Elise and Jessica standing on the stage. Ryan sends Elise back to safety next meaning Jessica Sanchez is singing for the save.

She's clearly shaken up and begins singing her save song and before she's two lines in, J.Lo's on the stage wrestling the mic away from her with Randy and Steven hot on her high heels. Randy declares her "the best singer in America" and says there's no way they're sending her home tonight.

So, Jessica's safe for one more week. But next week, two will go home.

What'd you think, America? Were you shocked that Jessica received the fewest number of votes last night?

 

Review

Editor Rating: 5.0 / 5.0
  • 5.0 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Miranda Wicker is a Staff Writer for TV Fanatic. Follow her on Twitter.

Tags:
Avatar

Judges -- even if they are right, they should not show, and more importantly impose to the public who they think should win...because it's up to the public!! otherwise change your format and let the judges decide. I think Hollie is the best and should win, Jessica is good but it is the people's vote that counts. The judges are a disgrace if it happened to Hollie they would not be able to get her off quick enough... THE THING THAT THE JUDGES DID IS LIKE LETTING OTHER ESPECIALLY HOLLY FEEL DUMP AND NOT WORTHY, HOLLY MY WHOLE COUNTRY "SAMOA" LIKES YOUR VOICE, JUST BE YOURSELF, NO MATTER WHAT HAPPEN, BE PROUD OF YOU ...... I THOUGHT THAT AMERICA DO RIGHT THING BUT NOW I KNOW IT NOT......

Avatar

well to me, I feels like the judges doesnt even know how to judge anything, I was really unhappy about what they did, NO ! if america's vote is already done then let it be, there are only 3 of them but the voting is done by billions of people and from that billions it included famous people who knows very well about sing and other stuff about american idol, so it seems that they don't care about the voting by america. and it is really unfair to other competitors to walk away and to give chance to others, HOLLY is a girl who always sings from her heart, everytime she sings it move peoples heart up, by I think that the judges cant hear that, SINGING is about giving good message, telling stories, emotions but NOT like YELLING, IT DOESNT MAKE EVERYONE FEELS GOOD ABOUT THAT. AND BY THE RECORD IT ONLY AMERICA WHO VOTE, IT ALL THE WORLD, SO PLEASE SING WITH THE HEART LIKE HOLLY BY NOT LIKE YELLING COZ IT DOESNT MAKES ME MOVES.

Avatar

This is kinda expected for a few reasons...
e
a) this is American Idol--unlike the first season AI(Search for the Singing Superstar), this has become a popularity 101 contest. The Best singer usually does not win... b) Judges -- even if they are right, they should not show, and more importantly impose to the public who they think should win...because it's up to the public!! otherwise change your format and let the judges decide. c) Underdog mentality -- because of reason b, the least deserving contestant gets sympathy vote, after being lambasted (sometimes unreasonably) by the judges. d) This is America--if they can put Dubya on the White House, the result is not that surprising actually =)

Avatar

Shame on the judges for making the four that were saved feel like they weren't worthy of being in the top 4. It's Americas vote.

Avatar

Karen, you got it right this time, the voters got it wrong...again!!!

Avatar

This is a sad commentary for the voters of this competition. It's crystal clear to me that the best singers were voted by you, the bottom three. I support Jessica, Josha and Alise. I've never voted, but I will from this point forward!!! WAKE UP AMERICA!!!

Avatar

I think Hollie is the best and should win, Jessica is good but it is the people's vote that counts. The judges are a disgrace if it happened to Hollie they would not be able to get her off quick enough.

Avatar

Kelly your a sick pervert

Avatar

There are only two contestants in this contest that one might label as being in the X Factor category, their names are Joshua Ledet & Jessica Sanchez, the rest are really only just so so.

Avatar

I believe Phillip and Skylar are the most natural and talented singers this year and I have felt that way since the beginning auditions. They seem to just flow without even trying. Both of them seem to be the most genuine and make me believe when they sing. I vote and pray for both of them.

× Close Ad