Special Grey's Anatomy Episode to Ask: What If... Comments (Page 2)
85 Comments
farsia2010 Rank: Recurring Character
December 9th, 2011 4:46 PM
this is what happens when screenwriters are desperate and they have nothing to write. this is getting soapy and i hate it. this season was so great i just wish they would have continues the heavily tense and dramatic season that they started and concentrate only on the core characters and stop deluding the mixture with this desperate attempted at versatility that is not necessary!
mama tiff
December 9th, 2011 4:59 AM
Well I don't know if I will like the "What if" episode. I love Meredith with Derrick. I liked Addy, but I like Meredith more. As far as bringing Meredith's mom back for the "what if" that has perked my interest. Don't really miss Issy Stevenson. Now George on the other hand. I was crushed when he was killed off the show. George was my Favourite person on the show. I was never a fan of what they did to him. I felt like he was always crapped on. Meredith crushed him, nobody like his wife Cally, Issy was so in love with him, then that didn't work out. Also, let's not forget, poor george had to be the one whom failed his inturn test and had to stay behind. Only to have little grey fall in love with him. Then he doesn't get to even notice her. Alex never likes him, Christina could take him or leave him. I just simply loved George. He should still be apart of the show. Then what a way to kill him off. The writers of the show couldn't even give him his own episode. He had to share the spot l
Silla
December 8th, 2011 7:29 PM
I think this is a good idea, that is if there will just be one episode like this.
I am wondering if Merediths mom will be with Richard. and although I dont want Issie to come back for good I hope to see her on this episode. and I would love to see George again. Im trying to guess whom Meredith will be with if Derek will still be with Addison. the only one i can think of is Finn, he was so cute :)
jules
December 8th, 2011 1:18 PM
If Derek and Addison never split, Mark might still be part of the show, because the whole reason Der ended up at SG is because of the affair. And if Ellis never got Alzheimers, I think Mer wouldn't be the great doctor she is now. She once said that if her mother hadn't gotten sick, she'd be like Alex. She'd still be dark and twisty bc her mum is a nightmare, so she'd still be friends with Cristina but she's probably be an alcoholic, either with someone (maybe Mark to get back at Derek?) or slutting around the hospital being the self-destructive Mer we saw in season 2.
This episode definitely had potential unlike the musical episode which was DOA and so painful to watch I almost stopped watching the show entirely.
As for the Mercy West-er, who gives a sh**? The only one who isn't annoying is Jackson.
aussie
December 8th, 2011 8:12 AM
Now that it's been confirmed Kate Burton is returning for this episode as Ellis Grey, I'm wondering if Ellis and Mer are actually working on the diabetes trial together which ties in with the storyline's of today. Take out Bailey insert Ellis.
Maybe they have a break through in their research, could be interesting.
My other idea would be that Mer is a resident in Neuro, Derek isn't really happy in his relationship with Addie, Der and Mer are flirting up a storm in the OR which turns into the affair.
Ellis is CoS instead of Richard too.
Kristen1998
December 7th, 2011 10:51 PM
If Ellis never had Alzheimer's, then Mer can't get it, right?
smileyglen Rank: Regular Character
December 7th, 2011 3:36 AM
Loving the If/Then concept.
So if Ellis is alive and doesn't have Alzheimer's, my theory would be Meredith would not have donated her liver to Thatcher, she wouldn't had the need to go seek him out, and Meredith would not have slept with George after there meeting, because she would know why they left Seattle for Boston all those years ago, she would of figured it out just by watching Ellis with Richard, Lexie may or may not have come to Seattle Grace.
The more I think about it the more I'm looking forward to February.
Renee
December 6th, 2011 11:19 PM
For the If/Then episode, I do not want to see again:
1) Erica
2) Sadie
3) Izzie
4) Reed
5) Charles
6) Callie's Father
7) Any of the O'Malleys except George
8) Sloane (I will turn off the TV is I see that girl!)
9) Ava/Rebecca
10)Denny (Loved the character, hated the storylines after S2)
11) Dr. Dixon
12) Rose
Although I understand we are going to see either Reed or Charles in this episode, I can bear one of them as long I don't get any of the other 11 listed above.
Mary
December 6th, 2011 11:07 PM
'Friends' anyone? Shonda?
Hope is a great episode though
Claudia47
December 6th, 2011 7:20 PM
I love this idea...I imagine Mer would be a very different doctor if her mother hadn't gotten sick. And the big question is, if Der stayed with Addie, who would Mer end up with, if anyone? Please don't let it be Alex...as far as I'm concerned, he is the one character without, well...character. Yes, he comes through once in a while, but you always get the impression he does it under duress, not from the heart...but that's just me.
Riona
December 6th, 2011 2:11 PM
Cant wait for this! I just really hope Izzie, and George come back, I love them! Also I'd like to see some Mark/Lexie or Mark/Callie scenes! ~
jude
December 6th, 2011 11:29 AM
Will the MerDer interaction that occured in the exam room have taken place, and how could Der have declared he had been in love with Mer forever if Der has stayed with Ad?
It'll be interesting to see if Der has built Ad a house in the woods and is paying more attention to his wife than he did prior to his moving to Seattle. I hope Der regrets his choice of being with Ad.
I do hope we see that Mer has moved on from her disappointment of loosing Der (in this dream). I'm not sure if Mer wasn't dark and twisty that she'd be such great friends with Cris. I could see there being more competition between them as residents for surgeries etc
Big foot would have to be the returning formerly shot doc cos if the elevator had been working he could have been saved. But I disliked him and I don't want him taking precious screen time from characters I prefer.
smileyglen Rank: Regular Character
December 6th, 2011 7:51 AM
This episode is going to be a dreamscape, from Meredith's point of view, or in Meredith's case it could be her worse nightmare. Addison and Derek are still together. The good news is Kate Burton who played Meredith's mother Ellis will be back too, along with Addison played by Kate Walsh.
It will be called "If/Then".
smileyglen Rank: Regular Character
December 6th, 2011 7:42 AM
Sorry "If/Then"
smileyglen Rank: Regular Character
December 6th, 2011 7:41 AM
This episode will titled "If/That".
smileyglen Rank: Regular Character
December 6th, 2011 2:02 AM
I hope it's Charles Percy that comes back and not Reed Adamson. Name me the other victims who died apart from those two???
Ellis minus Alzheimer's, would she still treat Meredith the same, she was career focused before the early onset Alzheimer's, would she work with Meredith? Would she have been the first female Chief of Surgery?
If Derek and Addison didn't break up, would they have had children?
So we would of still had the merger because one of the victims of the shooting comes back.
30 days til the next new episode of Grey's Anatomy.
Sam
December 6th, 2011 12:17 AM
So excitedddd!!!! I really love this show
I hope that there is a major episode too like v have every season about a breakdown or a disaster
Iv also heard that meredithz mum is also returning in this episode
Shortcake1
December 5th, 2011 10:23 PM
That would be an interesting episode....Let's see George doesn't die and he and Meredith end up together, McDreamy and Addison stay together, A love triangle between Callie, Arizona and Hahn, and McSteamy and Yang hook up and of course The Chief and Bailey get down!!!
leo
December 5th, 2011 8:30 PM
bring back han and burke!!
Grey's alicious
December 5th, 2011 7:08 PM
Um... so when is this all going to happen again? I want to see a new episode, NOW! You can't keep doing this to us, I can't wait until Feb!!
I am kinda over Izzie, and I want Lizzie and Mark to start some flirting!!!!
I know too many demands and questions.
Christina C
December 5th, 2011 5:20 PM
Oh i hope we get to see George or Izzie. Grey's Anatomy CANNOT do an episode without one of them... or else...
Danielle
December 5th, 2011 3:41 PM
Anyone think there's a chance they'll bring Isaiah Washington (Burke) back?
Olya
December 5th, 2011 3:18 PM
Do not bring Dr. Hahn back, it gave a very annoying vibe for the episodes she was in, because she was always so miserable and her voice kind of freaked me out.
jO
December 5th, 2011 1:41 PM
That would be so freaking awesome if they brought back Erica Hahn!!!!!!!
Steven
December 5th, 2011 12:40 AM
@smileyglen
Oh and remember, Derek rehired everyone that Richard fired when he became Chief in episode 613. Remember the scene with April and Megan?
Meredith: People change, but they don't change.
Rank: Recurring Character
December 9th, 2011 4:46 PM
this is what happens when screenwriters are desperate and they have nothing to write. this is getting soapy and i hate it. this season was so great i just wish they would have continues the heavily tense and dramatic season that they started and concentrate only on the core characters and stop deluding the mixture with this desperate attempted at versatility that is not necessary!
December 9th, 2011 4:59 AM
Well I don't know if I will like the "What if" episode. I love Meredith with Derrick. I liked Addy, but I like Meredith more. As far as bringing Meredith's mom back for the "what if" that has perked my interest. Don't really miss Issy Stevenson. Now George on the other hand. I was crushed when he was killed off the show. George was my Favourite person on the show. I was never a fan of what they did to him. I felt like he was always crapped on. Meredith crushed him, nobody like his wife Cally, Issy was so in love with him, then that didn't work out. Also, let's not forget, poor george had to be the one whom failed his inturn test and had to stay behind. Only to have little grey fall in love with him. Then he doesn't get to even notice her. Alex never likes him, Christina could take him or leave him. I just simply loved George. He should still be apart of the show. Then what a way to kill him off. The writers of the show couldn't even give him his own episode. He had to share the spot l
December 8th, 2011 7:29 PM
I think this is a good idea, that is if there will just be one episode like this.
I am wondering if Merediths mom will be with Richard. and although I dont want Issie to come back for good I hope to see her on this episode. and I would love to see George again. Im trying to guess whom Meredith will be with if Derek will still be with Addison. the only one i can think of is Finn, he was so cute :)
December 8th, 2011 1:18 PM
If Derek and Addison never split, Mark might still be part of the show, because the whole reason Der ended up at SG is because of the affair. And if Ellis never got Alzheimers, I think Mer wouldn't be the great doctor she is now. She once said that if her mother hadn't gotten sick, she'd be like Alex. She'd still be dark and twisty bc her mum is a nightmare, so she'd still be friends with Cristina but she's probably be an alcoholic, either with someone (maybe Mark to get back at Derek?) or slutting around the hospital being the self-destructive Mer we saw in season 2.
This episode definitely had potential unlike the musical episode which was DOA and so painful to watch I almost stopped watching the show entirely.
As for the Mercy West-er, who gives a sh**? The only one who isn't annoying is Jackson.
December 8th, 2011 8:12 AM
Now that it's been confirmed Kate Burton is returning for this episode as Ellis Grey, I'm wondering if Ellis and Mer are actually working on the diabetes trial together which ties in with the storyline's of today. Take out Bailey insert Ellis.
Maybe they have a break through in their research, could be interesting.
My other idea would be that Mer is a resident in Neuro, Derek isn't really happy in his relationship with Addie, Der and Mer are flirting up a storm in the OR which turns into the affair.
Ellis is CoS instead of Richard too.
December 7th, 2011 10:51 PM
If Ellis never had Alzheimer's, then Mer can't get it, right?
Rank: Regular Character
December 7th, 2011 3:36 AM
Loving the If/Then concept.
So if Ellis is alive and doesn't have Alzheimer's, my theory would be Meredith would not have donated her liver to Thatcher, she wouldn't had the need to go seek him out, and Meredith would not have slept with George after there meeting, because she would know why they left Seattle for Boston all those years ago, she would of figured it out just by watching Ellis with Richard, Lexie may or may not have come to Seattle Grace.
The more I think about it the more I'm looking forward to February.
December 6th, 2011 11:19 PM
For the If/Then episode, I do not want to see again:
1) Erica
2) Sadie
3) Izzie
4) Reed
5) Charles
6) Callie's Father
7) Any of the O'Malleys except George
8) Sloane (I will turn off the TV is I see that girl!)
9) Ava/Rebecca
10)Denny (Loved the character, hated the storylines after S2)
11) Dr. Dixon
12) Rose
Although I understand we are going to see either Reed or Charles in this episode, I can bear one of them as long I don't get any of the other 11 listed above.
December 6th, 2011 11:07 PM
'Friends' anyone? Shonda?
Hope is a great episode though
December 6th, 2011 7:20 PM
I love this idea...I imagine Mer would be a very different doctor if her mother hadn't gotten sick. And the big question is, if Der stayed with Addie, who would Mer end up with, if anyone? Please don't let it be Alex...as far as I'm concerned, he is the one character without, well...character. Yes, he comes through once in a while, but you always get the impression he does it under duress, not from the heart...but that's just me.
December 6th, 2011 2:11 PM
Cant wait for this! I just really hope Izzie, and George come back, I love them! Also I'd like to see some Mark/Lexie or Mark/Callie scenes! ~
December 6th, 2011 11:29 AM
Will the MerDer interaction that occured in the exam room have taken place, and how could Der have declared he had been in love with Mer forever if Der has stayed with Ad?
It'll be interesting to see if Der has built Ad a house in the woods and is paying more attention to his wife than he did prior to his moving to Seattle. I hope Der regrets his choice of being with Ad.
I do hope we see that Mer has moved on from her disappointment of loosing Der (in this dream). I'm not sure if Mer wasn't dark and twisty that she'd be such great friends with Cris. I could see there being more competition between them as residents for surgeries etc
Big foot would have to be the returning formerly shot doc cos if the elevator had been working he could have been saved. But I disliked him and I don't want him taking precious screen time from characters I prefer.
Rank: Regular Character
December 6th, 2011 7:51 AM
This episode is going to be a dreamscape, from Meredith's point of view, or in Meredith's case it could be her worse nightmare. Addison and Derek are still together. The good news is Kate Burton who played Meredith's mother Ellis will be back too, along with Addison played by Kate Walsh.
It will be called "If/Then".
Rank: Regular Character
December 6th, 2011 7:42 AM
Sorry "If/Then"
Rank: Regular Character
December 6th, 2011 7:41 AM
This episode will titled "If/That".
Rank: Regular Character
December 6th, 2011 2:02 AM
I hope it's Charles Percy that comes back and not Reed Adamson. Name me the other victims who died apart from those two???
Ellis minus Alzheimer's, would she still treat Meredith the same, she was career focused before the early onset Alzheimer's, would she work with Meredith? Would she have been the first female Chief of Surgery?
If Derek and Addison didn't break up, would they have had children?
So we would of still had the merger because one of the victims of the shooting comes back.
30 days til the next new episode of Grey's Anatomy.
December 6th, 2011 12:17 AM
So excitedddd!!!! I really love this show
I hope that there is a major episode too like v have every season about a breakdown or a disaster
Iv also heard that meredithz mum is also returning in this episode
December 5th, 2011 10:23 PM
That would be an interesting episode....Let's see George doesn't die and he and Meredith end up together, McDreamy and Addison stay together, A love triangle between Callie, Arizona and Hahn, and McSteamy and Yang hook up and of course The Chief and Bailey get down!!!
December 5th, 2011 8:30 PM
bring back han and burke!!
December 5th, 2011 7:08 PM
Um... so when is this all going to happen again? I want to see a new episode, NOW! You can't keep doing this to us, I can't wait until Feb!!
I am kinda over Izzie, and I want Lizzie and Mark to start some flirting!!!!
I know too many demands and questions.
December 5th, 2011 5:20 PM
Oh i hope we get to see George or Izzie. Grey's Anatomy CANNOT do an episode without one of them... or else...
December 5th, 2011 3:41 PM
Anyone think there's a chance they'll bring Isaiah Washington (Burke) back?
December 5th, 2011 3:18 PM
Do not bring Dr. Hahn back, it gave a very annoying vibe for the episodes she was in, because she was always so miserable and her voice kind of freaked me out.
December 5th, 2011 1:41 PM
That would be so freaking awesome if they brought back Erica Hahn!!!!!!!
December 5th, 2011 12:40 AM
@smileyglen
Oh and remember, Derek rehired everyone that Richard fired when he became Chief in episode 613. Remember the scene with April and Megan?