Wednesdays 10:00 PM on Comedy Central
South-park

18 Comments New Comment Subscribe

Hochberger

@Dave - Absolutely. I took the side I wanted to out of it and enjoyed it :)

Avatar

It is hilarious to read both the review and the comments. Everyone is trying to infer political meaning from all of this, but that's not how Trey and Matt work. This episode was not about approval or disaproval of the Occupy movement, Obama, the Tea Party, or any of the other things being insinuated. It is a satire that turns real-world events into silly events on a TV show. You can't read too much into it, as Trey and Matt have said time and time again. In reality, if you wanted to, you could take this episode to mean all sorts of things, but it's better to just laugh at the jokes, enjoy the episode, and leave it at that.

Avatar

Everybody who thinks Cartman is right about "they can't blame Obama": please think for a second. Would Cartman be right about anything? If you think he is right, if you use Cartman, of all South Park characters, to vindicate your political beliefs, you should seriously question your convictions. And possibly sanity.

Eric, I apologize for asking you to step down as a South Park reviewer in a previous comment. But could you maybe be a little less douchy about it? Like, I get that you don't like the Occupy movement. But does it have to cloud your judgement that much to not see that the "South Park treatment" was mostly given to the media reaction, not the protests itself? How many lines did the protestors have? How many lines the police? Did you notice the "Occupy Red Robin" story was invented by the media and our fourth graders didn't have anything to do with it? And you really think the afore-mentioned Cartman quote made fun of the protesters? No, it made fun of people like you, that apparently really think you can not be critical of black people (Herman Cain, anyone?). That is actually racist. That is why Cartman said it. Because it is racist. And Cartman is a racist.

Avatar

Lol, Kimberly you are delusional. They absolutely were 100% poking fun at the Occupy movement, in addition to the absurd media coverage and the 1% itself. And lol @ South Park slanting toward Obama, that couldn't be further from the truth. They slam idiots, which is why Glenn Beck, the Tea Party, and Obama have all been targeted, rightfully so. And why the fk would they possibly feel any need to apologize for the Man Bear Pig episode? They were dead on accurate in their assertions on Gore. Also while people understand the root concerns of Occupy, the movement itself is retarded because most of these people dont even understand what they are really protesting and the majority of them use faulty logic while being absurdly hypocritical at times.

Avatar

They were mocking the overreaction to the protests and by extension the substance thereof. They wouldn't be trying to present the media and police departments inordinately responding to the protests (and couldn't) unless they also thought that said protests are not, in their current form, to be taken seriously. Consequently, they satirize all aspects of the protests - those comprising them, those targeted by them, and those responding to them - in classic South Park form.

We also learned that Cartman is going to end up in a mental institution later in his life and that they are subtly continuing the "growing up/progress" theme they debuted in the mid season finale and premiere.

Avatar

Did we watch the same episode? I mean seriously. I saw nothing about the protests that was criticized. I saw criticism of the police and media's over reaction, and I saw criticism at how the 1% are playing victim and unable to dish out what they can take. Also they made fun of the 53% conservative splinter movement.

Your review reminds me of the episode of South Park where Cartman does mental gymnastics to try and slant everything to his world view. I know there are many South Park Republican's who are in denial about the direction that Matt and Trey have been taking in recent seasons towards more criticism of the Tea Party, Glenn Beck and conservatives and more sympathy towards Obama and liberals in general. This has been happening ever since the flea episode which acknowledged global warming. Their sort of apology letter for the Man Bear Pig episode a few years earlier.

They don't give liberals a pass either, they have become more moderate.

Anyways, to summarize the episode, it was 1% who did it, and they wanted to blame Token. But couldn't...because Cartman is friggin insane.

Avatar

Um, Cartman's "they can't blame Obama" quote isn't ridiculous, it's probably the best explanation for this Occupy stuff. This has been a fairly readily available critique, from all angles, since the beginning.

Avatar

awesome review and awesome episode, I'm going to try to link this to my fb page




You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register